Submitted 6 months ago by BeReady77@lemmy.world to [deleted]
I’m 20, I practice fencing. My height is 192 cm, I usually fence against shorter opponents. They often manage to drive their smallsword into my belly. That’s why I’m curious: what would it be like to get wounded into the belly by a real smallsword? How lethal would it be? How painful? How would I react?
You would probably say “ow, my belly”
Not sure about the lethality or pain level, tho.
Sorry, my reply was dumb. I don’t know what you said back, but it was probably completely justified. 😄
More something along the lines of “This but a scratch” and in the next scene you’re fully healed. Killing your opponent with the same stab, because it was plot convinient.
Dang I hate dune 2.
Complete layman answer here, but I would imagine it would depend on several factors:
I suspect it’d be extremely painful regardless of the above!
I think the cleanliness of the blade would be less relevant than the massive infection pouring from your pierced guts into the wound.
yeah, almost nothing on the blade would matter compare to the filth already inside your intestines. just a speck of that leaking into your body cavity will cause sepsis, and would be fatal without elephantine doses of antibiotics. stabbed with a sword? you’ll be in the hospital for a while. oh, and that’s not even including the massive tissue damage and blood loss.
plus, you’ll be luck to be leaving with your entire intestine intact (you’ll likely be osing a few feet of it) and not pooping into a colostomy bag for the rest of your life.
1d6 in piercing damage but hit to the guts is probably a crit so 2d6. If you are lucky you will just be very injured. If you are unlucky you will go down and start doing death saving throws.
It's fencing so I would make it a rapier which is 1d8+ Dex. But I agree about the crit. Better hope it's not a rogue....
Smallsword is apparently a separate weapon from rapier and 5e listed is as a 1d6. The reason I didn’t add anything apart from crit is because most people have NPC/villager stats so there wouldn’t be any stat bonuses.
That’s why you always have a cleric in your party.
Or a necromancer
Tldr it depends.
You might not notice with adrenaline pumping. As for lethality it really depends on where in your stomach you get hit and the care you get afterwards. In terms of the fight if it’s just your stomach area getting hit nothing shy of a spinal hit would instantly stop you. If they hit an artery you’ve got minutes. If they puncture your intestines and you can’t get care days, before infection catches up to you.
For the actual conflict the only things that will instantly stop are central nervous system hits (brain/spine). Heart and lungs are the next worst, but wouldn’t stop you from claiming a pyrrhic victory. Major arteries are the next big thing to worry about.
The worst part about getting hit in a non vital part of the chest wouldn’t be the force of the blow but the slow agonizing battle with infection that is not unlikely to follow. But absolutely livable and not nearly as bad with modern medical care.
bookshop.org/p/books/…/10628914?ean=9781933016412
Book is written by a doctor for writers. Explains how a real world injury should be written in a story.
There’s a saying you want someone dead you shoot them in the head.
You want someone to suffer you shoot them in the gut.
It can be a slow miserable death as your body slowly goes into shock and dies. I’d imagine a blade would have a similar story.
There’s many critical structures to avoid such as a network of nerves sometimes referred to as angel pasta. There’s arteries and your gastrointestinal tract. Any of these being stabbed can game over or irrevocably alter the course of your life.
Your best bet is a stab that doesn’t go through your core but parallel like through the fat layer of your stomach.
If you’re doing Star Wars cosplay, you’ll be totally fine. Unless you’re wearing the Qui-Gon Jinn costume, then you’re screwed.
They invented Bacta about 20 minutes after Qui-Gon got stabbed. Bad luck.
ooh right in the midichlorians! that’s a dead-i.
Look up “disemboweled”
Then look up “degloved”
protip: don’t
Yeah, don't do that. Also, it's not related to the question. Just horrifying.
Assuming it perforates the intestine - big infection from fecal matter getting into the abdominal cavity. It's called peritonitis, and AFAIK it's pretty much fatal if untreated. Severe abdominal pain as the infection spreads, all the vomiting and diarrhea cleans you out, and then the infection starts to shut your intestines and the rest of your organs fail while you go into sepsis and die. It's not fast, either. It can take several days.
Initially you would not feel anything due to adrenaline. However after a moment, it would hurt so profoundly that it would command all your senses and drive you into a coiled fetal shape on the floor as you writhe in uncontrollable pain until either someone smashes your gut wound with so much immense pressure or becomes difficult to breathe in order to keep you alive until you are taken to a hospital or you quickly succumb to sepsis from your actual shit in your own intestines leaching into your blood slowly spreading bacteria towards your brain and you die painfully.
You seem to be rather fond of this sort of question
That’s just out of curiosity
if stomach gets cut, the acid could flow out. Death by being dissolved by your own stomach acid wouldnt be nice one.
It’s actually the bacteria that’s a bigger issue. Your digestive tract is isolated from main body functions in a number of key ways to prevent shit in your food and bowels from getting into your blood stream - if they do bridge that gap it can be nearly impossible to recover even with modern medicine. Septic shock is an extremely common cause of death.
One of the shows I’ve been watching had this as its twist, part of a cliffhanger. There were hints before but you can’t not object to a short sword embedded in a guys belly having so little impact
jws_shadotak@sh.itjust.works 6 months ago
Beyond initial bleeding - extensive gastrointestinal issues, depending on where it hits. If it lacerates part of the intestine, it may leak feces into the abdominal cavity. It would require flushing and antibiotics to prevent going into sepsis from massive infection.
If it does enough damage, you could be looking at removing a portion of the intestines and possibly requiring a colostomy bag.
Abdominal wounds are no joke. The liver bleeds profusely if lacerated or punctured. All of the blood flow to the abdomen exits through the liver into the inferior vena cava.