The entire ‘mainstream’ gaming media is a laughably obvious corrupt set of marketers, advertisers and social media managers.
That is all, thank you for attending my TED talk.
Submitted 1 day ago by sp3ctr4l@lemmy.dbzer0.com to games@lemmy.world
The entire ‘mainstream’ gaming media is a laughably obvious corrupt set of marketers, advertisers and social media managers.
That is all, thank you for attending my TED talk.
“You can tell, because they don’t share my correct opinion!”
There has always been an implicit pressure on media outlets to rate highly anticipated titles well. If they don’t clap when the light turns green, they might not get a review copy next time.
I completely agree, and even said this in the review thread, but people conflate skepticism with immediate negative unfounded accusations.
“Electronic Arts releases a game…”. “IT’S PROBABLY FUNDED BY AIPAC!!!”
I’m just being patient to see what the next month of reviews are. And even then I probably don’t care because I have many own tastes.
The outlets that have survived this long are no longer depending on traffic from review scores, except for IGN. There are very few outlets like IGN left, and if you haven’t noticed, most of the rest of them have shifted to subscription models off of small, sustainable audiences instead of ad revenue. Publishers do select their day 1 reviewers based on who they think will review it most favorably, but the incentive for outlets no longer depends on pre-release access.
Which opinion? He didn’t even play the game yet.
I thought red dead was a 10/10. This is even better. Like I don’t. Get why gamers are so butthurt that rockstar gave us another GTA. I think there’s only one game ive ever shit on and that was bulletstorm.
Whys it worth whining if you don’t like something? it’s not going to change anyone’s opinion on it. Gaming is a hobby. Let people enjoy their hobby how they like.
Personally I think this GTA 6 is going to keep me entertained for years to come
Like I don’t. Get why gamers are so butthurt that rockstar gave us another GTA.
That isn’t the complaint.
The complaint is that this game is being widely reviewed with perfect scores, when the game is very obviously not perfect.
The complaint is about how game reviewing ‘standards’ work, or rather, seem to be entirely arbitrary and thus meaningless.
If you enjoy GTA6, more power to you! Genuienly, if you love this game, and I don’t, that is a-ok, and I am happy you enjoy this game! If this game brings you joy for a decade, then I will be glad for you that it does.
I am not saying you are not allowed to enjoy this game.
I am saying it does not deserve a perfect score. Many of these perfect score reviews even literally state ‘this is not a perfect game’, yet give it a perfect score… when for scoring other games, the same problems that they say GTA6 has … caused those other games to have lower scores.
The complaint is about consistency and standards in game reviewing. It is about obvious favoritism and double standards.
The complaint is not … that GTA 6 exists.
Saying this as a lifelong gamer - why give even the slightest shit about what games journalists say?
If you like a game 96%, then it’s not a perfect game, but that rounds to 10/10.
The complaint is that this game is being widely reviewed with perfect scores, when the game is very obviously not perfect.
That’s not how 10/10 scores work. Between a perfect score and one point less is a huge gap, so that 10/10 isn’t that extraordinary like 100% scores. A game doesn’t have to be perfect, because no game is perfect, to get a perfect score. It just means its one of the best games of its generation, compared to what games are out there and what the system can deliver. And then there is a personal opinion involved too.
Reviews are opinions. Siskel and Ebert shit on a lot of great movies and loved some awful ones.
I think its fair to say its close to just a reskin, and that business model has had a negative impact on the gaming community.
Its OK for anyone to like a new version of the same game, look at COD and fallout London, but just like COD its important to differentiate the dev/artist team from the board of directors.
This game will be used to extract money from gambling addicts, and will be incredibly profitable. It probably also only released now due to the market cooling on GTA V online, and paid their devs the absolute minimum they could without bad PR.
(also try gaten of banban if you want to shit on a game lol, but at least there we know the moneys not just going upstream)
Even if it’s a reskinn which it’s not just borrowing some old assets . It’s a completely new story, and exploring is most of the fun of these games
Ah, Bulletstorm, the game most of us got to play the Gears 3 Beta a week early. I did still enjoy it, but never touched it after finishing it once.
Or they just liked the game.
Check any of them for other games they gave a perfect review to.
You we see the double standards.
People are allowed to like more than one thing, even things you don’t. What a crazy concept huh?
You know a 5/5 is also a perfect score. What is your obsession with that? 10/10 just means one of the best games of the generation. And they can like a game that you don’t like. There are hyper niche games that wouldn’t get played and liked by most, and there are games that most people can appreciate.
You didn’t even play GTA 6 yet, but have an opinion about the game. And call everyone who think its a 10/10 a corrupt place.
…Both can be true?
It can be a historic, great game. And also have the best reviews money can buy.
Rockstar can be kinda shit, yet have extremely talented employees.
That, and high-SEO gaming media being bought out has been well documented for over a decade
Did I at any point say anything like ‘GTA6 is a totally garbage 0/10 game’?
No.
Did you… think that I did, for some reason?
…?
But beyond that… yeah I basically agree with you.
GTA6 certainly is a massive feat, no doubt! But its… pretty obvious that these 150 or so literally perfect score reviews are… yeah, bought and paid for, directly, indirectly, out of fear of losing access, etc.
10/10 doesn’t mean “perfect”, because frankly nothing is.
I saw a gif of a plane crash explosion animation in GTA6 and it’s hilariously bad. So right there, automatically, the game cannot be perfect, I found a criticism. Would I remove 1/10 for that criticism? No.
I think this thread is all the evidence I need for how broken the voting system is in place of forums. Lies and conspiracy theories get upvoted, become the “truth”, and folks are just going to become more divorced from reality.
You needed further evidence? This whole place exists because reddit became such a flaming dumpster fire of circle jerking.
And unfortunately, this place isn't that far off from that itself.
This whole thread feels very manufactured.
Games journos are just corporate shills - many of them actually wrote in their reviews “GTA VI isnt perfect…” then proceeded to give it 10/10.
Bunch of clowns.
I have no interest in GTA 6. I haven’t played a GTA game since 3 on the PS2. So I get that my opinion is pretty meaningless.
But its 2026. Not hitting 60 (natural) FPS on modern high end hardware means you failed to achieve the minimum performance floor. DNF/100.
Did you play GTA 6, that you call others opinions being corrupt? Why is a 10/10 for GTA 6 corrupt? Which game in your opinion deserves this score?
“Its about ethics in gaming journalism”
Jokes aside, yeah, the industry is a bit plagued with veiled guerilla marketing and Stan culture dressed up as journalism, and the critic industry writ large(this focuses on movies but applies to gaming too) is in a bit of a crisis moment and GTA6 is coming at a point of upheaval and decline in the AAA gaming industry and this is the event of the decade…..it’s getting an artificial boost cause of that. It’s also objectively the most technically impressive game ever created.
It’s also objectively the most technically impressive game ever created.
If this is objective, you then must have general metrics that can apply broadly to similar games by which this can be measured.
You’d need something like a bunch of actually measurable data points, and then a way to combine or blend them into some kind of ‘objective measure of technical impressiveness’, which itself, the combined metric, would also need to be widely agreed to be the best way to measure that.
Its fine for that to be your opinion.
Objective?
Prove it, I don’t believe you.
24 fps during the player running around and blowing shit up?
That is not very impressive. Its actually laughably bad.
If you have experts that are more technically competent at making these judgements, have at it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qsBU0bcpONA
Read my other posts, I am not even a GTA fan, but you come off like the bitch eating crackers meme with this stuff
I get the last line is a hyperbole, but as someone who didn’t buy because I assumed it was a reskin, whats changed?
Rockstar is a shitty company but they clearly have good devs, so its always cool to hear what they make.
No one wants to be the one who doesn’t
True… but that doesn’t make them not corrupt.
Its a form of the ‘chilling effect’ regarding political speech.
Instead of self-censoring, everyone is auto-aggrandizing.
Like how everyone was terrified to be the first person to stop clapping for Stalin.
Can agree, the game will bring hella lot of fun. May play once on pc even and bet if/when i do, will get fun.
But it is flawless and perfect? fuck nope. It is worthy $80? $100? $100 AND monthly fee for gta+ cut off content? hahahahahahha gonna wait for free on epic store probably?
Is it 10/10, definitely nope, we saw lots of bugs, very weird content, like painting walls woah impressive waste and chore of gameplay. probably it is solid 8+, maybe 9.
Then corrupted journalists, who added that 1-2 points on top of that, saying the game is any elite… yeah, do not trust any big journalist on the market, they are working for money, not for trust. Same goes for dev contests, awards or prestige - it’s a tier list of who paid most.
I've worked for three places using Oralce databases.
Guess what? All three of them won some sort or Oracle innovation award or whatever.
They must think their customers are really fucking stupi . . . oh, they are.
Bingo!
I have no problem with someone giving this an 8 or 9.
Yep, its got some bugs that need to be worked out, personally, I don’t think its nearly as much of a step in the directions I was hoping it would or could be, in terms of gameplay…
But I have different preferences than other people.
But, but … … a perfect score?
From 150 different gaming media outlets?
Horseshit.
Nah, you’re just coping because Rockstar Games are assholes, but the new GTA is the most 10/10 game I’ve ever played (a couple hours so far).
Absolutely astonishing everything that cramed into that game and how absolutely gorgeous it looks 99.9% of the time. 30FPS had me worried at first but it strangely feels a lot smoother that one would expect. Definetly played games at 60+ FPS that felt much worse
Do I believe that some games are hivemind loved ? Yes. Do I believe some outlets are paid to like something ? Yes. I think Sony did that heavily in the ps4 gen to ensure everyone mentioned the ps4 was “superior” to the Xbox version. Is it possible to that a game is just that universally liked ? Yes ! Think BOTW, OOT.
All of these things by can be true depending on the context. If be spent a lot of time with GTA / Rockstar games in the past. And most of the praise to me is warranted. They are games jam packed with content.
And I’m sorry but just saying GTA 5 reskin is grossly wrong. It’s a Red Redemption 2 reskin … and it’s still good.
popcar2@piefed.ca 1 day ago
GTA 6 being successful and well loved has completely broken the average lemmy user and now we have to suffer through dozens of posts coping about it for weeks to come. Dear god.
Kichae@piefed.ca 1 day ago
It’s ok, we just have to weather release week. Then the game awards. Then Christmas. Then the GDCAs. Then the BAFTAs.
Hopefully by April they’ll have tired themselves out.
orochi02@feddit.org 14 hours ago
I still understand bc of how shitty rockstar is but it really is beyond me how people can compare to to generic bs like battlefield, cod and fifa smh