AliOski
@AliOski@feddit.nl
- Comment on #SBA 303 Launch Break 3 days ago:
Nooooo we can’t postpone the launch! That would be terrible for the president’s reputation! Those O-rings will be just fineeee don’t worry!
- Comment on Slept like a baked potato. 3 days ago:
Holy shit im tired.
I read the title of this post as “slept like a bald person” 💀 I was like “what…?”
- Comment on Thoughts 4 days ago:
When it cannot be considered as sperm cells.
- Comment on Thoughts 5 days ago:
The cum would be dissolved in the stomach by all the acids and probably also absorbed by your intestines as useful nutrition.
- Comment on [deleted] 6 days ago:
Damn… 2017 is already almost a decade ago…
- Comment on A day gone by 6 days ago:
Creative one
- Comment on Any advice appreciated 1 week ago:
[…] I do not see why you would not consider the process.
We were talking about saying to a person that they should have never existed or saying to them that they should be better off dying. A person that already lives has already experienced suffering. However, from the current moment onward, there is still a lot of suffering left. Preventing the suffering before somebody’s birth or while they are already alive would be equivalent. Maintaining/returning to the ground state only matters for the future, what happened already happened. So essentially: allow the person to suffer in the future or not? That choice is equivalent for a nonexistent being and a living being.
So yes, I understand that nonexistence and death are not the same in every context, but in our discussion, it is equivalent. The past doesn’t matter because you can’t prevent suffering that already happened. You can only prevent current and future suffering.
This is an entirely different scenario. By denying food, you impose suffering (hunger) on an already existing being.
Well it’s difficult to make an analogy that is entirely correct… Your moral dilemma assumed the act to be immoral to begin with…
How is it the peak of meaning “for the rock”? If we agree that the rock is not sentient, cannot experience, and is not morally considerable, how can we conclude that it is the peak for the rock? The meaning is entirely external to the rock, and I don’t see how the absence of this external meaning matters if there is no subject to experience it.
Excuse my English, I am not a native speaker. With “for” I more so meant that the meaning is given to the rock, and with meaning I more so meant a ‘broader meaning’ to the universe. Again, not a perfect analogy…
I do not understand your argument here. This sounds very much like an appeal to nature. Are you making the point that all ethical conclusions must be in alignment with nature? Rape, cannibalism, and infanticide are all natural and are observed across multiple species. The universe doesn’t care about these things. Why should we care about any of them? I do not see how something being natural makes it obligatory.
No no no not at all what I’m saying. The things you mentioned are phenomena from nature that are not required to exist. Trees don’t rape each other. I meant the fundamental ‘law’ of natural selection. That’s almost like a physical/mathematical/statistical rule of nature. Anything that is not sufficiently able to survive or procreate will go extinct, meaning only the things that are sufficiently capable of those things will remain. Trying to ‘beat’ natural selection is not possible, so in the grander scheme of things, the only thing you are accomplishing with not procreating is your bloodline ending and other beings that are capable of procreation taking your place. In short: it doesn’t really matter in the long run, the ‘suffering’ you’re trying to prevent will just keep on going, just not with your DNA in the gene pool.
I am noticing that this discussion has derailed quite a lot and I think we won’t see eye on eye on this issue. Some fundamentally different world views. And kind of getting stuck in the same arguments. Let’s leave it at this.
- Comment on [deleted] 1 week ago:
I understood that if a game was offered DRM-free and as a Steam key, you would receive both. Looking at the store page now, it looks like you need to choose which one you want to purchase in a drop-down menu? Can anybody confirm whether they changed the functionality? That wouldn’t be just a change of layout but a fundamental functionality difference. A negative one.
- Comment on Nothing pops the biggest stock market bubble of all time like a couple of extramarital affairs. "Artificial intelligence" is not match for natural instincts. 1 week ago:
…but a cheating CEO isn’t going to get millions of investors to dump a few TRILLION in stocks.
If it were just that you might be correct. But it isn’t just that.
This might be the drop that causes the bucket to overflow.
- Comment on how to be a shit friend 1 week ago:
😈
- Comment on Any advice appreciated 1 week ago:
Would it be morally permissible to commit an immoral act if the sufferer were to be mildly compensated?
You are saying this with the pretense that the act is immoral. That pretense is what I am disputing. I would equate it with giving somebody dinner each day (dinner being life and each day being a new generation). The first day it is horrid food, maybe even sand. The person is hungry though, and they eat whatever they can. Sometimes this means they eat sand. Sometimes this means eating shit. Sometimes this means eating a bug. The next day, there are a couple berries. Keep going for years and you have a royal dinner. Yeah, in that royal dinner there sometimes still is stuff you don’t like eating. Sometimes it has been poisoned by somebody. Or it is simply rotten.
Is it immoral to give somebody dinner even though you don’t have much to give them or there is risk of it being poisoned? Is it more moral to not give them anything at all and refuse them?
Nonexistent “beings”, however, are not subject to your predicaments. They do not need to experience joy or suffering, nor do they need to learn the necessity of “falling and getting back up”, or find the meaning of death. You are projecting your views on the beauty of the universe onto a being that neither experiences nor needs to experience it. There is nothing in it for a nonexistent being.
Death and nonexistence are for the being equivalent. They are the ground state.
Let’s imagine a rock. It has been laying still on the ground for hundreds of thousands of years. Suddenly, for a few minutes, some animal/human takes that rock with them, plays with the rock, experiences memories with the rock, good or bad ones, and then gets left behind again, for the eternity of time. It would not mean much to the rock, but to the animal/human it did mean something. It was the peak of meaning for that rock. I would argue that this is why it is better to give somebody life instead of not.
Again, I believe you are conflating existing beings with nonexistent ones. I would consider a child’s life utterly valuable once they exist. However, I maintain the view that it would have been in their best interest not to be brought into existence in the first place. Also, the phrase “it would be better if you weren’t alive” is highly ambiguous. “Weren’t alive” can imply death, which seems to negate the value of their already existing life. That is not what I am doing here. To someone who would not misconstrue me or be emotionally hurt, I’d rather say something along the lines of “I am so sorry, it would have been in your best interest not to be brought into existence”.
Again, nonexistence and death are equivalent for the being themselves in my opinion. Being dead is being nonexistent except as a memory or the physical existence. To me, telling somebody that is suffering from life that it would have been better to not have come into existence at all is equivalent to telling them it would be better if they died this very moment. You are telling them the “ground state” would be preferable for them. That’s in essence what you are saying. I do not see how already being alive changes this “preferred” ground state to you.
Regarding humanity as a collective, I somewhat agree with you. Creating the next generation reduces the probability of the current generation dying a miserable death. However, my point regarding this was that “kicking the can down the road” is not a good and permanent solution; it merely increases the collective suffering in the long run.
I personally have a very “biological” stance on the collective meaning of life. Our ‘function’ is to procreate and persist as a species. That is how our DNA has been trained due to environmental circumstances. That is how all life has been trained. I take this function that has been given to me through the selection of all my predecessors before me very serious. Like some sort of duty. In normal circumstances (historically), we would be too busy surviving and staying alive to even question the meaning of existence. It is when survival is not the primary thing being done when we lose sight of what we are “supposed” to be doing. What we are “made for”. Ethics can not come to this conclusion because the universe didnt care about ethics when it created life. It just happened. You can either accept the nature of the universe and play in accordance to its rules or deny it and follow man-made ethics that would ultimately destroy humanity. Or well, “naturally select” the humans that do in fact play in accordance to the rules of the universe.
- Comment on mrbeast crypto scam 1 week ago:
- Comment on totally not magic 1 week ago:
Certified schizo post
- Comment on 1 week ago:
In the library section there is a button to go to the store page though… even when that page is hidden
- Comment on baking 1 week ago:
What did it say originally instead of “dirt”?
- Comment on pass it on 1 week ago:
Certified shit post
- Comment on Where no man has gone before 1 week ago:
Exactly lol
- Comment on Any advice appreciated 1 week ago:
My point was not that it is always good for a person to procreate. Every person has their own special circumstances that would each need their own weighing of the situation. I would not tell a 16 year old to procreate, for example, and I would also advice against procreation in the case of a woman close to their menopause. Again however, these advices are already more nuanced and based on the specific circumstances of the individual at hand.
My point is that in a general sense, when talking about the concept of procreation itself, it should not be adviced against. In any case not with such a lack of nuance as in that text. I do not regard the “passing on of the problem” to be a valid argument against procreation. The problem is carried by humans as a collective and through the years it has been getting better and better.
Neither do I think that “prevention of potential suffering” is a valid argument. There is no joy without suffering and no life without both. Without bad there is no good. Life is about falling and getting back up. It is the essence of life. It is what gives life its worth. Would you choose not to be born at all in order to prevent your death? What even is the meaning of death if you’ve never been alive in the first place? To me not being born and death are equivalent: being alive is the short span in the eternity of the universe where you can experience the beauty of essence itself.
I personally can understood when you are 100% certain that the kid will have a birth defect that you might not want to have the child suffer under it. However, in many cases even those people are enjoying life just fine. People with down syndrome are famous for enjoying the little things in life and being full of happiness, despite the suffering.
In any case, the worth of the life of the child was to me a given and not even up for debate. I do not believe that children with bad parents shouldn’t have been born. Imagine telling somebody with bad parents “it would be better if you weren’t alive”. That’s obviously not moral. They would agree with you if they hated themselves, but I would not regard this as “good for their mental health”. They too deserve a happy life, despite their bad parents. Their life still has a lot of potential and it could still be worth it, despite all the trauma.
So what is left, if the child’s life is valuable in all cases? Just the concerns of the parents. And well, you already understood my thoughts on that. On an individual basis you might advice against procreation. In a general sense, never.
I haven’t even really talked about the interests of humans as a collective.
- Comment on Where no man has gone before 1 week ago:
I had a discussion on Reddit about how farting into space isn’t possible…
Too bad I can’t access it anymore because they restricted my account due to age verification.
- Comment on We're back, baby!!! It's bean time 1 week ago:
Beans make me shit
Certified shit post
- Comment on Choose wisely 1 week ago:
Beans make me shit
Certified shit post
- Comment on Choose wisely 1 week ago:
Shit god
- Comment on Any advice appreciated 1 week ago:
The logic this author is using is “you will by definition traumatize your children, thus you shouldn’t have children”. Not only is this completely flawed logic, even if it were true that by definition you will traumatize your children, doesn’t mean you shouldn’t have children, but it also inherently says “you will traumatize your children”. So they are basically telling you that you would be a bad parent. Isn’t that offensive? I understand, every parent has flaws but that’s not the same as “fucking up your children”.
Apart from that, the “disgrace” remark comes from the inherent malevolence of telling people to stop procreating. Telling people to grow old living miserable lonely lives without the innate happiness of having children and being a parent. Having your own children that look up to you and (unless you are indeed a bad parent or if there is something seriously wrong with the child) will love you almost unconditionally. There is no joy better than having children. Telling people to not experience that joy is in my opinion disgraceful.
I can understand the economic realities that sometimes prevent the opportunity of giving your children a happy life, but that’s not what this author/person is talking about.
- Comment on Found this in a workplace toilet today 1 week ago:
Interesting, very ordinary
- Comment on Any advice appreciated 1 week ago:
Horrible text. Telling people to not have kids. Disgraceful, just offensive.
If the first paragraph applies you just had bad parents or there is genuinely something wrong with the child themselves.
- Comment on Found this in a workplace toilet today 1 week ago:
Maybe it is because I am not a native english speaker, but why is the feces/poop/shit called “number 2 waste”? Never heard of that expression.
- Comment on Did somebody say 'RAM' ? 1 week ago:
Good one
- Comment on Oh It Gets Worse. Much Worse. 1 week ago:
Lol, lmao even. Depends on the major and the university/college 😂
- Comment on If you're brave enough... 1 week ago:
You won’t believe me. I shitted that.
- Comment on [deleted] 1 week ago:
I dont have Redout 2