Skyblivion team says a former volunteer is threatening legal action against the fan-made Oblivion remake in a dispute over code they contributed.
The very fact that a threat to sue was possible and that the team preferred to roll back / remove the code indicates the situation was not legally clear cut when the code was submitted in the first place. And, come on, this was solved in the 90s!
Did the submitter sign a legal document, backed by the project, to waive their rights and ownership of the code to the project specifically? If so, this is done. If not, this is done too.
riskable@programming.dev 2 weeks ago
What a douche. When you submit code to a project, you agree that your code will fall under that project’s license. If it’s under an open source license, there’s no “backsies.”
Relevant metaphors:
urushitan@kakera.kintsugi.moe 2 weeks ago
As far as I can tell there is no public source code beyond a few tools they use, and many those repos have no license. So while his actions are shitty, he didn’t legally give them code. From what it sounds like, he gave them a compiled asset with access to his source code, then revoked access to his source code repository, so they decompiled the asset and he’s suing them for that. Which he may have legal grounds to do,because I’m guessing this was occurring in the “let’s all make a mod together!” and there likely isn’t a formal contract signed that says “anything you contribute to the project is ours.”
disorderly@lemmy.world 2 weeks ago
I’ve worked on a few projects like this and there is a general expectation that if you contribute code built against a system you maintain separately from the shared project, you grant permission for the project to continue using it when you leave.
I’ve also seen people threaten to sue on every one of them, and the one person who actually did got fucking rinsed.
Katana314@lemmy.world 2 weeks ago
I hate that I’ve worked at companies where some employees, searching the web for code, think that “no license” means anyone can use it copy-pasted for any purpose.
I’m thankful that Stack Overflow and similar sites set in their terms that submissions become free to use, but in general blogs, it’s not an automatic conclusion.
bss03@infosec.pub 2 weeks ago
Unfortunately, more projects should get this “in writing”. GNU projects prefer copyright assignment, but (I think) many of them also accept just a clear licensing statement (“This is mine and no one else’s; I give it under the project license.” but in legalese).
If there’s no clear statement, a judge many very well issue a preliminary injunction against the project distribution, just so they have time to gather and review evidence, even if the actions of the contributor are later found to show intent. With a dated statement containing the contributor identifier(s), a judge is much more likely to accept an initial motion to dismiss (even with prejudice).
FenrirIII@lemmy.world 2 weeks ago
He’s either got to have trademarked the code or have to prove damages