The fact that so many people believe socialism as it presently and historically exists was and is “totalitarian” is precisely by design. The common sense of any society is the ideology of the ruling class, the structures put in place by communists to fight against capital and cement working class democracy are utterly alien to most of us who live only in capitalism, and therefore it’s easy to confuse them for not being run by and for the working class.
Comment on I'm on Lemmy to commiepost and chew bubblegum. And I'm all out of gum.
ininewcrow@lemmy.ca 19 hours ago
Sometimes I wonder if all the commie hate is just by design to stop anyone and everyone from even remotely thinking about any socialist ideas at all.
I get that totalitarian communism and socialism is a terrible idea … but at the same time, we shouldn’t scorch earth the idea of socially leaning government or even social democracy entirely to the point where we only ever want to think that the current political reality we exist is the only way to go.
Cowbee@lemmy.ml 11 hours ago
lugal@sopuli.xyz 8 hours ago
The thing is that socialism is much broader than Bolshevism. There is anarchist critics from Marx’ time that aged very well. By conflating socialism and Bolshevism, capitalists make everything to their left look bad while Bolsheviks find allies in people who would fight against them if there were more alternatives.
captainlezbian@lemmy.world 7 hours ago
Exactly, there were even communist rebels against the USSR
Osan@lemmy.world 19 hours ago
The hate for leftist ideologies is just the result of years of right-wing, capitalist and fascist propaganda combined with the history of some fucked up dictators doing their shit in the name of communism or socialism just how fucked up fascists do their shit in the name of religion and the greater good.
Cowbee@lemmy.ml 11 hours ago
The history of socialism and communism is told by the capitalist class, outside of socialist countries, and thus our views on their histories are a part of that right-wing, capitalist, fascist propaganda. It isn’t just “communism bad,” it’s also exaggeration of problems, minimizations of successes, and fabrications or distortions of events and people.
TrickDacy@lemmy.world 18 hours ago
Sometimes I wonder if all the commie hate is just by design to stop anyone and everyone from even remotely thinking about any socialist ideas at all.
If that’s true, then the rabid tankies we see on here are truly a psyop
Cowbee@lemmy.ml 11 hours ago
Nah, the group modernly called tankies have existed for well over a century. People can get heated when they are often surrounded by misconception after misconception, thick with the propaganda of the Red Scare. Despite what people like to believe, nobody is actually immune to propaganda.
imadethis@fedinsfw.app 8 hours ago
Totalitarian communism and socialism…
Whoah, my lover, let me stop you right there. Communism is a stateless, classless society, by definition. If you have a government, you don’t really have a communism, see? And socialism is also a far cry removed from what you seem to picture it as. The workers owning the means of production doesn’t really tell you anything about governance, does it?
AHemlocksLie@lemmy.zip 7 hours ago
stateless
Wouldn’t that be anarchist instead? I thought communism typically came with a state, just one made to serve the needs of the people.
Osan@lemmy.world 3 hours ago
The state (dictatorship of the proletariat after a revolution) in a Marxist communist philosophy is only a temporary situation as means to reach the goal of a stateless (anarchist) system eventually once capitalist counter-attacks are fended off and resources are redistributed eliminating class differences.
Both anarchism and communism share a very similar goal they just terribly disagree on how you reach that goal and whether the state apparatus will gradually disappear on its own eventually or should’ve we gotten rid of it from the beginning.
surewhynotlem@lemmy.world 7 hours ago
See, leftist ideology is a lot like CrossFit or veganism. There’s nothing wrong with it. It’s probably good for you. But the most annoying people in the world just can’t shut up about it.
And before anyone says it: NoT AlL VEgAnS/CrOsSFiTs/LeFtisTs
Godric@lemmy.world 7 hours ago
Mine’s mostly born of constant tankie atrocity denial and downplaying.
Image
Gyrcas@piefed.zip 7 hours ago
Yeah, fuck tankies and any authoritarian leftists, but keep in mind not all leftists are like those
Godric@lemmy.world 7 hours ago
Most of the ones I see are happy to defend authoritarianism, so it may be the vocal asshole problem.
Gyrcas@piefed.zip 7 hours ago
I feel you, three big instances of Lemmy are filled with them, I just blocked all three on my side. I consider myself an anarcho-communist, and I’ll say it again and again, fuck Stalin, fuck Lenin and fuck Mao. These three fuckers ruined the reputation of the left for decades because they were power hungry assholes