Submitted 10 months ago by memo@feddit.it to games@lemmy.world
https://backloggd.com/u/serime/list/adult-casts-in-jrpgs/
Hi! I’ve been working on a list of RPGs (mostly japanese or j-influenced somewhat) in which the cast is mostly adults. The list is hosted on backloggd.
Leaving it here both in case it may be useful to anyone, but also in case you spot any missing titles that you believe should be added :) cheers!
I enjoyed The Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky, in large part because most of the party members are adults. Exceptions are the two protagonists, a princess (whose station more or less demands she act above her age), and a pre-teen girl whose main character trait is being an engineering assistant to an inventor in a factory town.
Meanwhile, the fun bits of the adult party members included seeing them get drunk at inopportune times, attempt to impart their adult wisdom on the two leads, hit on random strangers or each other, and occasionally be even more childish than the kids they’re accompanying. It felt like a good group.
I played some of the games that came afterward, starting with the Crossbell games and continuing with Trails of Cold Steel, and a significant reason I stopped was that the WHOLE cast was school-age kids, to the point that it really started feeling like modern anime, and not in a good way.
The high school shift is certainly jarring coming from a team of professionals in the Crossbell games, though at least it does shift to a mixed focus in Cold Steel 3 and 4, and then back to professionals in Reverie.
Thank you! Indeed, Trails in the Sky has been on my backlog for a while and for good reason, from what I hear. I remember looking at screenshots for the subsequent series like Trails of Cold Steel and generally it was a turnoff starting from the art/design direction.
In this regard, I think that Persona 5’s success is both a blessing and a curse: blessing, because it showed how JRPGs don’t have to be action oriented to be beautiful; curse because Atlus surely realized, already back with Persona 4, that the high school setting somehow seemed successful, thus somehow suggesting to the industry that it is a good model to follow.
Oh, I just looked at a wiki for the upcoming game (already out in JP) Trails Through Daybreak and it seems like the cast is at least balanced between teenagers and adults! I’m more than okay with this if written nicely and without creepy/disturbing tropes.
I haven’t followed that one so much; seeing a blue-haired male lead using a sword, and no sign they were moving away from dedicated “relationship events”, overall didn’t seem like the direction I wanted. I’m not quite sure the age of characters was my only issue with the series.
This is a great compilation!
I would add an asterisk to FF12…the game starts off with a lead male child protagonist who wants to impress or rescue or whatever a female child playable character.
After the first chapter or so of the game, those two characters are completely irrelevant to the plot of the game, which is actually about the cast of adults.
Yes, the children are still there. Yes you have to control the boy as your overworld avatar.
There are some other children with more plot relevance, some of whom join the team.
I think the youngest plot-relevant child on the team is 19, but overall it’s not a “children save the world” plot.
Fair question! After I grew up to around 21/22 I felt like I had a harder time resonating with young teens in JRPGs - more often than not there’s also either awkward/creepy tropes in many of those that make the game and the characters much less appealing to me. I guess I would genuinely prefer to spend my time on media starring adults to avoid that? I don’t know, I was honestly more curious as to how many games I could rack up that fitted such a specific research more than anything.
I just assumed there was a court order requiring you to stay at least 50’ from all underage video game characters.
Parasite Eve and Persona 2: EP were always a bit striking to me in this regard especially because they are in modern-day settings. Also, they both don’t have a young child joining the party at any point, which is a thing in a lot of the games in this list.
Dragon’s Dogma
Wugger@lemmy.world 10 months ago
I like it. Almost all jrpgs and anime these days are targeted at children or adults who like anime for children. I miss when there was more content made to appeal to adults.
Katana314@lemmy.world 10 months ago
The funny thing is, I don’t think even this is a right way of looking at it. I think variety in the characters you view makes them more interesting; adult characters can definitely come across as heroic even to kids. It’s not necessarily excluding them as an audience.
memo@feddit.it 10 months ago
This! I mean, if we take a well-known and loved example, Goku is 18 by the time the first Dragon Ball series ends up, while being around 23 at the start of Dragon Ball Z. Also, I don’t think it’s bad to have a teenager as the main character once in a while, but we have to admit that it happens a little too often and in dubious way in japanese media in general. That’s because it sadly has a market, and it’s ever-expanding too, as @Wugger@lemmy.world said.
Cybersteel@lemmy.world 10 months ago
I just don’t like children. The world would be better without them
Cybersteel@lemmy.world 10 months ago
I just don’t like children. The world would be better without them