Why the hell do deaths under communism always seem to include every person who died from any cause not from old age, while the deaths of fascism only include people who were executed?
Comment on YOU HAVE HURT THE FEE-FEES OF THE CHINESE PEOPLE!1!!!
gastroglizzy@piefed.social 2 weeks agoHitler executed about 8 million people, about 6 million of whom were jews.
Stalin starved about 20 million people.
Mao oversaw the Great Famine, following his order to kill all the sparrows in China, which lead to the starvation of 60 - 80 million people, depending on who’s counting.
psycholocomotor_no2@lemmy.blahaj.zone 2 weeks ago
Jiggle_Physics@quokk.au 2 weeks ago
Also, how so many gloss over the MANY famines suffered under capitalism. Ones that range into the 10s of millions as well, and it wasn’t just one Great Famine, the British alone are responsible for like a dozen, or more, across their empire, especially if we are discussing the Pakistani/India/Bangladesh region. Ones where there was food, but that food had a high profit margin, so knowing that there wasn’t enough other food to go around, they still shipped it to places that would not have seen mass famine had they not received that food. The most famous being Ireland’s, because they are the white Europeans that suffered from these economic policies. Not to mention the absolute insanity that was European colonialism in sub Saharan Africa. However, we like to talk about those like they happened in isolation from each other, or as a consequence of acts of god. Total leading to well over the 100 million claimed to have been the consequence of communism, and which is disingenuously bloated.
Mao sucked. Harsh authoritarian, was 90% of the support for the Khmere Rouge, had no fucking clue how to run a country he took control of, etc. However he isn’t quite the outlier people make him to be when you really examine what happened under the capitalist empires.
psycholocomotor_no2@lemmy.blahaj.zone 2 weeks ago
Yeah, like I think part of the reason they keep bringing up Hitler is that he basically colonized Europe, while far worse things happened in colonized Africa and Asia.
logi@lemmy.world 2 weeks ago
Because a communist dictator coming into power is often followed by severe mismanagement and famine and the deaths of millions. It’s not the same sort of evil as killing people deliberately, but they’re equally dead.
tutter@lemmy.blahaj.zone 2 weeks ago
So, all the famine, death and destruction caused by capitalist exploitation of third world countries like india and most of the afrives continent can also directly be tied to that right? Then its at least a intellectually consisten framework youre operating under.
And doing that, the most conservative death toll, from WHO, is around 9 million excess deaths, A YEAR.
multiply that by, again lets be conservative and lets say just the last 30 years. So from the middle of the nineties to now, thats 270 million excess deaths just from imposed famine like conditions. So no even counting other deaths following the exploitation of workers and ressources in third world countries
if we just do the math, it seems capitalism is many orders of magnitude more deadly than even psychos like Stalin.
logi@lemmy.world 2 weeks ago
So, all the famine, death and destruction caused by capitalist exploitation of third world countries like india and most of the africsn continent can also directly be tied back to capitalism right?
Sure, if that’s the comparison you’re making. But “capitalism” Vs Mao is not a comparison that makes sense.
You could maybe count Churchill’s famine in India or his jolly little wars in Africa if you want to be argumentative. Or just accept that Mao caused millions of deaths through pig-headed incompetence and move on.
psycholocomotor_no2@lemmy.blahaj.zone 2 weeks ago
No, actually, just no, colonialist regimes and fascist regimes killed far more people consistently than even incompetent communist states. The deaths of millions every year under neocolonialist comprador governments in Africa and Asia and South America happens silently every year.
Communist dictatorship is better than a totally inhuman dictatorship of capital. I legit believe this.
logi@lemmy.world 2 weeks ago
I’m not even disputing that. I’m just saying Mao done fucked up. And if that triggers you, then you’ve got a problem.
tutter@lemmy.blahaj.zone 2 weeks ago
So, all the famine, death and destruction caused by capitalist exploitation of third world countries like india and most of the africsn continent can also directly be tied back to capitalism right? Then its at least an intellectually consistent framework youre operating under.
And doing that, the most conservative death toll, from WHO, is around 9 million excess deaths, A YEAR.
multiply that by, again lets be conservative and lets say just the last 30 years. So from the middle of the nineties to now, thats 270 million excess deaths just from imposed famine like conditions. So not even counting other deaths following the exploitation of workers and ressources in third world countries
if we just do the math, it seems capitalism is many orders of magnitude more deadly than even psychos like Stalin.
rzadkie@lemmy.world 2 weeks ago
Oh, genocide denier I see… Hitlerites murderd 13 milion people in camps and other genocidal pursuits. Why are you minimizing the deaths of industrial genocide and emphasizing deaths of poorly timed policies?
Also fun fact, treating beneficial animals, insects and plants as pests was nothing new at the time and continues into the present. But why bother to investigate things you’re talking about am right?
Objection@lemmy.ml 2 weeks ago
Wikipedia lists the range of estimates for the famine as 15-46 million, so your numbers are beyond even the high end of that.
It also lists the number ]killed by the Nazis](en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victims_of_Nazi_Germany) in mass killings as 11 million, which doesn’t account for at least 39 million combat deaths in the European theater of WWII, which Hitler started.
I’m not sure why you feel the need to minimize Hitler’s death toll or inflate Mao’s, as if even the lower range was not a dismal failure. The policy was so much of a failure that overall life expectancy in China stagnated, before continuing it’s meteoric rise. You can see it very clearly around 1960 in this graph:
Image
Glide@piefed.ca 2 weeks ago
Hmm…
Image
Objection@lemmy.ml 2 weeks ago
Relevancy?
psycholocomotor_no2@lemmy.blahaj.zone 2 weeks ago
They’re saying that (I thonk) the life expectation rise after the PRC was established is just coincidental with a global trend of life expectancies rising and that communism had no role in improving life expectancy.