Objection
@Objection@lemmy.ml
- Comment on 1 day ago:
Very true.
- Comment on 1 day ago:
Well, after Nazi Germany was defeated, all the top levels of government were tried at Nuremberg in a special tribunal, many of them executed, and then the new German governments had the chance to win the people’s trust.
That.
- Comment on Im not conservative enough to be a liberal 4 days ago:
well established in general usage.
Only in the US. The “Liberal Democrats” in the UK are not understood to be the opposite of the Tories, and there are many similar cases in countries around the world.
The reason liberal is understood to mean the opposite of conservative in the US is only because historically socialism became such a dirty word, liberals did everything they could to distance themselves from it, and there was no major socialist party or movement.
Since socialism has become resurgent, it makes more sense, especially on an international platform like this one, to adopt the internationally understood meaning.
- Comment on Bad news 5 days ago:
That kind of honesty on craigslist is a rarity.
- Comment on ¿How communism actually work in practice? 1 week ago:
Rather than imagining jumping straight into communism directly, let’s look at what it would mean to move towards it gradually.
Right now, people have to work in order to provide the basic necessities of life, like food and housing. However, suppose the state provides those things at little or no cost, without changing anything else. The profit motive still exists, and people work for pretty much the same reasons as before. If you want to buy a big TV, video games, a boat, whatever, you have to work for it. Money still exists, and is still valuable, but it’s not essential.
Suppose I’m in a relationship I’m unhappy in, but I feel the need to stay together because of rent. If rent is no longer a concern, then I’m now more free to decide who to date based on things other than money. Then, someone who might otherwise be focused on money as a way of attracting a partner, might try to appeal to them in other ways, by showing off physical fitness, creativity and artistic skill, education, etc. Then, perhaps a company appeals to that person by offering a way to develop skills, rather than just money.
To use a fictional example, in Star Trek, everyone’s basic material needs are met, but you still have groups like the Ferengi who are focused on profits and money, which is often used for rare goods and collectibles. Many people don’t seem to have much use for it. While money still exists, it’s not really the same as we think of money today, because the things it’s used for are so much more limited.
Of course, we can’t just abolish money overnight, but what we can do is work towards a world people are free to act on motives other than making money. And future generations growing up in a world where money isn’t essential might look at it in a completely different way than we can even imagine.
- Comment on The Odds Are Good When The Goods Are Odd 1 week ago:
Fair enough.
- Comment on The Odds Are Good When The Goods Are Odd 1 week ago:
Yeah I mean I’m not saying it’s the same level I’m just saying I’ve heard the same logic. “Just because I say [n-word] doesn’t mean I hate black people, I only hate the ones that act like [n-words].” You’ll hear the same justification for just about any slur whenever anyone challenges it. “Nothing against people with mental disabilities, I just hate people who act like r-----ds.” “Nothing against queer people, I just hate the ones who act like f----ts.” Anyone who recognizes that it doesn’t hold up in those cases should understand that it doesn’t hold up here.
But they have no answer to that, so all they can do is act like I’m equating the two, when in fact the whole point is to use a more extreme example to more clearly demonstrate the problem.
- Comment on Lemmy users logging on to level set the Blue Wave enjoyers 1 week ago:
If that. There’s already articles and polls speculating on the race. Hell, there was an article on here making a big deal over Trump not endorsing Vance for president, before the midterms had even happened. We are getting closer and closer to the eternal campaign season.
- Comment on Lemmy users logging on to level set the Blue Wave enjoyers 1 week ago:
For a couple of weeks before the 2028 election season starts.
- Comment on The Odds Are Good When The Goods Are Odd 1 week ago:
Cool, good thing I’m not then.
- Comment on The Odds Are Good When The Goods Are Odd 1 week ago:
I’ve seen people use that exact justification for the n-word.
- Comment on Elections Have Consequences 1 week ago:
You just said that it was.
- Comment on Elections Have Consequences 1 week ago:
It’s possible to learn things or better understand how and why people think differently from you by talking, and putting it on the internet doesn’t somehow change that. So I don’t consider it pointless at all.
- Comment on Lemmy users logging on to level set the Blue Wave enjoyers 1 week ago:
Once Mississippi and Alaska are confirmed it’ll likely be 56-44. If you’re not familiar with how the US Senate works, only a third of representatives are up for election each time. A lot of states have been considered solidly red or blue for a long time (with little change even with all the shit Trump has done up to this point), with only a handful of states being seen as competitive, but Democrats broke that gridlock in many states that people would’ve thought impossible. Kansas hasn’t had a Democratic senator in nearly a century.
The senate was designed to limit popular momentum, but conversely, it also means that the senators that were elected yesterday won’t be up for reelection for another 6 years. It’ll be difficult if not impossible for the Republicans to regain control before then. If Democrats win the presidency in 2028 (which seems likely with Trump being unpopular), then we’ll be looking at a Democratic trifecta, which hasn’t happened since the first two years of Obama.
Also, Texas going blue is monumental. It has
a bajillion40 electoral votes in our stupid system so it fundamentally reshapes the path to a presidential win. - Comment on Lemmy users logging on to level set the Blue Wave enjoyers 1 week ago:
I’m curious, if someone supports the death penalty in general, not in the context of a socialist state, is that “psychotic harm” that’s equivalent to Nazi atrocities? Like, I would disagree with that, but equating it to Nazism is pretty ridiculous. As far as I’m aware, every country has had the death penalty at some point in it’s history, so they all have Nazi pasts?
This is really quite silly. It’s basically like saying that anyone who supports the existence of states is a Nazi because the Nazis had a state.
- Comment on Lemmy users logging on to level set the Blue Wave enjoyers 1 week ago:
I did. I see a bunch of .ml’s clearly and strongly saying that we don’t believe in accelerationism.
- Comment on Elections Have Consequences 1 week ago:
Fact is, I could very easily find 5-10 sources, but you would likely just find some nuance that proves your point while ignoring all the nuance that proves my point. It’s pointless.
Then talking is just as pointless! You’re assuming that I’d dismiss your sources without even giving me the chance to look at them in good faith. That itself is bad faith.
Are you saying that democrats, either as individual politicians or colllective groups that represented the party, were not the ones peddling ideas associated with “woke 1”. Are you saying the ideas of “woke 1” in its entirety weren’t actually bad, but it was perceived as bad unfairly?
Yes, both of those things. The ideas that the democrats espoused during that time were not as radical as they were perceived. More radical ideas were espoused by random individuals who were nowhere near to the levers of power. Now, obviously, I can’t vouch for every idea on every 15 year-old’s Tumblr blog, but whether ideas that random people had were good or bad is beside the point.
“Woke” is a flexible word that can mean basically anything. If you want to define it such that it’s in line with the Democrat’s former policies, then fine, my position is that “woke” ideas were not that extreme or bad. If you want to define it as including more extreme positions, then my position is that the Democrats were not as woke as people think. But just alluding to these vague concepts makes it impossible to actually evaluate anything and ground it in facts. Which is why I’ve been trying to shift the focus onto specific policy positions.
Which brings me back to my question of whether there’s anything in Clinton’s 2016 platform regarding trans rights that goes beyond equal protections and privacy rights, the same sorts of things that El-Sayed supports. If you stop talking about these “perceptions” of vaguely defined terms, and look at specific policy positions, then we can have an actual, grounded conversation, that isn’t just your memory of a perception against my memory of a perception, which obviously goes nowhere.
- Comment on Elections Have Consequences 1 week ago:
I got better things to do with my life than to dig up sources to defend my opinion to a random person on the internet
If you have better things to do than source your claims, you probably have better things to do than to make them in the first place.
I love polling podcasts as they are pure numbers and facts.
Well, facts about people’s perceptions of things.
I do all this so when I need to have an opinion on something, I don’t need to spend hours “doing homework”. If I felt like I didn’t understand something and needed to research it, I would.
Then I would think that providing a source would be trivially easy. You’re saying that you’ve already done your homework, you just didn’t want to show it to me because… I don’t really know why. Like, when I ask for a source, I’m asking where your information is coming from. If your information is coming from a podcast, then cite the podcast. It’s not a question of whether you’ve researched it. Do you think of sources as proving to some teacher that you put effort in? They’re about showing the reader where the information comes from, so they can evaluate follow along and evaluate it themselves.
I didn’t know what “woke 1” meant, I googled it and found an article that seemed to validate exactly what I’m saying. “Woke 1” is not used as a good phase of the democratic party. Period. The end. That still not good enough for you? Fine.
The perception of “woke 1” being bad is something I never once disagreed with. What I disagreed with was whether that perception reflected the actual reality of what the Democrats said or did.
- Comment on Lemmy users logging on to level set the Blue Wave enjoyers 1 week ago:
I’ll take that as a no, then.
- Comment on Lemmy users logging on to level set the Blue Wave enjoyers 1 week ago:
You were told that there are discussions on .ml and elsewhere about whether China is socialist. But you assume that the people saying it isn’t are the same people saying it is. The reality is that .ml and other leftist spaces don’t represent a monolith, we don’t have some official party line everyone has to accept. There are some users who argue that China is socialist and some who say it isn’t, there is no contradiction unless you assume those two groups are the same people, rather than just being on the same instance.
- Comment on Elections Have Consequences 1 week ago:
Christ, finally. The amount I have to twist people’s arms on this website to do the most basic homework to support their positions. It’s completely ridiculous.
That article is very scant on details and specifics. It mentions “defund the police,” which was mostly a slogan used by activists rather than the party, and which, as the article mentions (and as I mentioned previously) never actually went anywhere and was walked back, with Biden calling specifically to “fund the police” and with many places raising police budgets instead. In spite of this, there was a perception that Democrats actually did defund the police. Not the reality.
It doesn’t really talk about democrat’s positions on trans rights at all. It mentions #MeToo, and one random state assemblywoman who talked about cancelling Thanksgiving.
My whole point is not that there was no perception of the Democrats being woke, but that it was just a perception. Nothing in that article actually challenges that. It just quotes other people who had that perception. You can say, “politics is about feelings and perceptions” but all that makes me think of is how Republicans “felt like” Obama turned the country into a socialist republic.
Here is a Ballotpedia page for Hillary Clinton’s stances on LGBT rights in 2016. I would love to know which parts of it are “particularly pro-trans” rather than just keeping the government out of trans people’s business and ensuring equal protection under the law.
- Comment on Lemmy users logging on to level set the Blue Wave enjoyers 1 week ago:
- Comment on Lemmy users logging on to level set the Blue Wave enjoyers 1 week ago:
Yeah? Can you show us one?
- Comment on Lemmy users logging on to level set the Blue Wave enjoyers 1 week ago:
Lmao show us anybody claiming any of this shit.
- Comment on Elections Have Consequences 1 week ago:
The time we’re discussing when the Democrats were supposedly “too woke.”
- Comment on Elections Have Consequences 1 week ago:
He basically said the government doesn’t need to get involved.
That’s literally what the Democrats were saying in “Woke 1.”
- Comment on Elections Have Consequences 1 week ago:
I’m not so sure. I think they might need Americans to come civilize their countries by bombing their families and killing their children. Sure, some women will be killed in the process, but it’s all in the name of feminism. And yeah, we might take some oil and resources while we’re there, but surely we deserve a bit of compensation for carrying on the White Man’s Burden.
- Comment on Elections Have Consequences 1 week ago:
Lol, now you’re just making shit up.
The point is with this sort of narrative that isn’t really based on hard evidence in the first place, virtually anything that happens can be spun to support it, and the inconvenient parts just glossed over.
As for El Sayed, I’m not saying everybody has gone full anti-woke. I’m just saying the Democratic party has chilled out in general. There’s gonna be exceptions.
So what you are saying then is that everybody had been woke. Because otherwise, if it’s just that there are some politicians that are woke and some that are anti-woke, and it was like that before, then nothing’s really changed.
But that’s the thing. Not everybody in the party was woke. And if you relied on actual evidence instead of memories and feelings, you’d see that that’s obviously true. If everyone had been woke, that raises the question of why wasn’t there legislation that you can actually point to?
If anything, politicians generally didn’t really talk about trans people or have clearly defined stances, until Republicans decided to make it a central issue of their campaign.
- Comment on Elections Have Consequences 1 week ago:
I think you’ve blindly accepted this narrative as dogma without any real evidence and anything that happens you could just twist into supporting the narrative. If Talarico and Hamilton had lost, you’d just say that it shows they were too supportive of trans rights, since they won, you say it’s because they weren’t fully supportive of them. Meanwhile, the example of El-Sayed is just written off because he doesn’t fit the narrative you already decided on. It’s nonsense.
To me, this reaction from the community was a problem.
Both politicians and the community.
Ah, see, there you have it. The community. When people talk about the left going too far, what they mean is almost always like some random Tumblr blog with 10 followers.
Guess what? There are still random Tumblr blogs with 10 followers saying all sorts of crazy things, wielding zero political influence just as they did back then. Fucking, saying crazy shit is part of growing up, part of sorting out ideas, and some of the “crazy shit” that’s taken to represent “the left” is literally just some 15 year old. You’re never going to enforce any kind of “party discipline” across everyone in the country.
What’s changed is not that teenagers suddenly stopped saying crazy shit, or lost the power they never had in the first place, but that the Republicans fucked shit up badly enough that people started having better things to worry about. And to some extent, people have just become more accustomed to the internet and the fact that there are always people saying all kinds of shit and it doesn’t fucking matter. And frankly, the most woke shit by the edgiest teen could barely compete with the shit Elon Musk tweets out regularly to huge audiences anyway.
So, in my opinion, this whole narrative is bullshit based on nothing but memories of perceptions.
- Comment on Elections Have Consequences 1 week ago:
That’s completely shifting the goalposts. Whether Republicans viewed the Democrats as being woke is an entirely different question from whether the Democrats actually were woke. Republicans believed Democrats for reasons I already explained, in my first reply and elsewhere in this thread.
The reality is that the Republican perception of the Democrats had more to do with their own minds and their own circles and their own conditions, rather than what Democrats actually said or did. Many of these people are just diehard reactionaries and unreachable.
Also, Democrats won midterm races regardless of what their stance on trans rights was. El-Sayed for example did not (to my knowledge) adopt any anti-trans positions, and politicians like Talarico and Hamilton (Kansas) conceded on sports but overall had positive messaging.
This is exactly why it’s important to ground your narratives in hard facts rather than vague memories, because if you compare politicians’ rhetoric then to now, how much has it actually shifted? It’s more that Republicans overplayed their hand on the issue, while also fucking up in other, bigger ways, like in Iran. So the rhetoric that’s remembered as being “too extreme” and the rhetoric that’s seen as “reasonable” could be the exact same words, and what’s actually changed is people’s perception of that rhetoric. Which is meaningless for the conclusions and narratives you’re drawing.