Comment on Every base is base 10
Wizard_Pope@lemmy.world 4 months agoSame here. I read all the comments and still don’t understand the joke.
Comment on Every base is base 10
Wizard_Pope@lemmy.world 4 months agoSame here. I read all the comments and still don’t understand the joke.
DogWater@lemmy.world 4 months ago
From the aliens perspective 4 is 10 and it’s represented that way so, while having a different meaning, to the alien it is base 10.
Wizard_Pope@lemmy.world 4 months ago
I see that but why is it 10 from his perspective? Is it just the fact that the alien would write the number 4 with symbols for 10?
whotookkarl@lemmy.world 4 months ago
www.mathsisfun.com/numbers/bases.html has a bunch more examples to show why the base of the number system is always represented by 10, because 10 is a short hand we use for d1b^1 + d2b^0 where d is a digit between 0 and base-1, and b is the base. b^0 is always one and represents the first digit at the first position. b^1 is the base, so 1b^1 = the base. And since 10 is 1b^1 + 0*b^0 it represents the base in any number base system.
Another way to show the same thing with counting:
Base 10: 0, 1, 2, …, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12… Base 4: 0, 1, 2, 3, 10, 11, 12, 13, 20, … Any base: d1b^0, d2b^0, …, d(b-1)b^0, d1b^1 + d1b^0, d1b^1 + d2*b^0, …
We assume a 1 in the 10’s place and a 0 in the 1’s represents 1,2,3,…,10 of something instead of 0,1,2,3,10 of something because from our perspective we learned numbers in base 10 with 10 digits, but the alien learned 10 means 4 of something in base 4.
wolfpack86@lemmy.world 4 months ago
And the same that 3 in base 3 is also 10, 2 in base 2 is also 10. Thus if you use the relevant base to refer to themselves, every base is base 10.
snugglesthefalse@sh.itjust.works 4 months ago
Assuming they use the same numbers then yes, 10 is 10 to us but it represents the separator of orders of magnitude. 10 in base 4 would from our perspective be 4, but ignoring the specific numbers and adapting them for the sake of the joke, the alien would write it as 10 and “base 10” would just be base 4. It’s like how hexadecimal uses 0-9 and a-f to represent 16 numbers even though we don’t have that many in decimal systems. The joke is a translation issue. I feel like I’m over explaining now though…
DogWater@lemmy.world 4 months ago
These people are explaining it well, but the things that helps the most to me is consciously de-coupling your internalized knowledge of human Numbers from what they actually represent abstractly. The numbers represent an absolute quantity.
0 =
1 = .
2 = . .
3 = . . .
That’s 4 unique characters representing incremental quantities.
If you notice on the comic, the alien has 4 digits on it’s “hands”. That’s the root cause for their base number system. Ours is that way because we we have 10 digits on our hands (most of the time, some cultures do it different, but for simplicity, that’s what the comic is implying).
Abstractly, adding another digit represents starting over and keeping track of how many times you’ve done that. So the 1 in ten says you’ve counted through all the digits 1 time. And the 0 means you’re on the first digit of the new sequence. So all they are doing is applying that logic to a base 4 system. So a collection of 4 things is therefore represented by “one zero,” 10, in base 4 because they have to, there are no more characters in that system.
The weird part about it that can trip people up is that they are applying some human conventions to the comic like our script for writing numbers, which obviously an alien wouldn’t do, but we have so much inherent ingrained knowledge about what a number means that it’s hard to remember that.
OldManBOMBIN@lemmy.world 4 months ago
Yes