Devolved?
Which of the listed nations on the bottom were revolutions that overthrew functioning free and fair democratic systems?
Comment on Putin too, for some reason
RememberTheApollo_@lemmy.world 6 days ago
Millions killed in purges and policy created in cults of personality.
Yeah, need to make a whole identity sh*tting on imperfect democracies while touting systems that have always devolved into dictatorships.
Devolved?
Which of the listed nations on the bottom were revolutions that overthrew functioning free and fair democratic systems?
Why the f does that matter? They existed as they did, killed multiple millons, so don’t butwhatabout and redirect.
Cause you said they all devolved into dictatorships and that is factually inaccurate.
Every example in the OP is from a revolution that occurred in response to an existing non-democratic, capitalist, authoritarian state.
So the revolutions took over states that were in fact not democratic. This is not a moral judgement but a clarification of fact.
Another clarification is the notion of “Have Always”
Do you think those listed are the only examples?
Care to explain the Paris Commune? Allende in Chile? The socialist republic in Spain? Arbenz in Guatemala? Lumumba and the pan african movement in Congo? Nicaragua? The PKI and Sukarmo in Indonesia? And then in East Timor? Just to name a few
DarkCloud@lemmy.world 6 days ago
Or you’re just not that familiar with Capitalist and Communist history.
Killed by the British East India company by the famines in India and Bengal: 10 - 15 million.
Killed by the Congo Free State under King Leopald: 10 - 15 million.
Killed in the USSR Gulag system? 1.5 - 2.5 million.
Most people survived the Gulag system.
Outside of that Communism had a lot of unwanted famines largely contributed to by one con man scientist:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trofim_Lysenko#Consequences…
Capitalism has in all likelihood killed way more people than Communism… And if you know the history, this becomes more and more obvious. This doesn’t even cover the many wars by Capitalist nations.
kolmaskommentoija@sopuli.xyz 6 days ago
Others doing bad things, does not make you doing bad things any better. Do you really want to defend “only” around 2 million people dying, and 18 million more ending up in camps?!
DarkCloud@lemmy.world 6 days ago
It’s not really about that … I mean, we don’t live under communism, we live under the deadlier of the two systems.
kolmaskommentoija@sopuli.xyz 6 days ago
Well, then we get to the definitions of communism, because neither Soviet Union nor China under CCP have been marxist communists. “True communist state” would be owned by people, not people subjugated to become possessions of a dictator too. Capitalism fucking sucks, but I will rather take the social democratic system I live under now, than a dictator throwing innocent people into camps. (And that applies to the USA too, with their dollar-store government doing their best nazi impression right now.)
Now, if only we could stop being such meek sheep, we could perhaps figure out a system that is not based on exploitation. But that would be not like Capitalist societies, nor anything like Soviet Union or China under CCP.