danielquinn
@danielquinn@lemmy.ca
Canadian software engineer living in Europe.
- Comment on Why DS9 is still best Star Trek 2 weeks ago:
It was really hard to read without the formatting, so I’ve fixed it below:
One thing Star Trek could never do today is introduce one of its main characters as an unrepentant anticolonial terrorist, and then spend seven seasons stubbornly refusing to make her apologize for having been one.
Major Kira Nerys grows enormously over Deep Space Nine. She learns that individual Cardassians aren’t interchangeable. She befriends some of them. She confronts things the Bajoran Resistance did that were ugly. So the show gives her every opportunity to arrive at the comfortable conclusion you’d expect. She never does.
In Season 5, a Cardassian civilian confronts Kira about a Resistance bombing that killed twelve Cardassians, including the family of the military officer who lived there. He asks whether she feels guilty, and Kira’s answer is astonishing from a modern perspective:
“None of you belonged on Bajor. It wasn’t your world. For fifty years you raped our planet, and you killed our people. I don’t care whether you held a phaser in your hand or you ironed shirts for a living. You were all guilty, and you were all legitimate targets!”
Kira isn’t some villain whose radicalism exists so Captain Sisko can spend the next five minutes explaining the enlightened Federation position. She’s not an extremist who eventually realizes that both sides went too far. She’s not even a former terrorist who has matured enough to be embarrassed by her younger self.
She is the first officer of Deep Space Nine. She may be a complicated hero, but she is objectively a hero. Over the course of the series, Kira changes her understanding of people without ever fundamentally changing her understanding of power. She accepts that an innocent Cardassian doesn’t deserve to die solely because he’s Cardassian. But the Cardassian occupation of Bajor was maintained by an entire colonial society, not merely the soldiers holding rifles – and Kira still believes the Bajorans had the right to make that occupation unbearable.
That’s an incredibly uncomfortable distinction, and DS9 lets it remain uncomfortable. Which is probably why Kira feels like a character from another political universe now.
After 9/11, American television certainly didn’t stop making complicated or even sympathetic terrorist characters. But the terrorist became a problem to explain: How was this person radicalized? Can they be redeemed? Have they renounced violence? Are they secretly still dangerous?
What they don’t do is show terrorist characters saying “yes I did it, and I’d do it again” while remaining the hero.
Nana Visitor herself noticed the difference years later. Talking about whether Kira could exist after 9/11, she said she couldn’t imagine playing her quite the same way. Other shows could have complicated terrorist characters, she observed, but the audience was always being asked to question them. “Kira, never.”
And that’s the genuinely subversive thing about her. DS9 doesn’t ask us to discover that Kira was secretly right about everything she did. It shows us innocent people harmed by the Resistance. It lets victims call her a murderer. It lets Kira herself recognize moral boundaries she didn’t always recognize before. But it never requires the colonized person to condemn her own resistance before we’re allowed to consider her a hero.
By the end of the series, Star Trek does something even stranger: when Cardassia itself falls under Dominion occupation, the former Bajoran terrorist is sent to teach the Cardassians how to become terrorists. The imperial power that once hunted Kira’s resistance suddenly needs exactly the knowledge her resistance produced.
Eventually the people who called her a terrorist needed her to teach them how to resist an occupation. Turns out terrorism looks a lot different when you’re the one being occupied.
orignal source: Facebook
- Comment on Why won't MPs tax the rich? 2 weeks ago:
Corruption? How dare you sir/madam! Corruption is what those dirty little countries have! Here in the UK we have evolved beyond corruption because we’re rich, civilised and um… white… or something.
No this is just doing business. Nothing to see here. Get back to work.
- Comment on [Video] Footage of the Board of Deputies of British Jews resurfaces where President Lionel Kopelowitz called for Corbyn to be sacrificed for all the trouble he caused. 3 weeks ago:
I like how the response is “Quiet! Someone might hear you!”. As opposed to " What the fuck is wrong with you?"
- Comment on I work in the food industry – and the UK is heading for full supply-chain collapse 3 weeks ago:
Has Labour been any better?
- Comment on Heat pumps and insulation would cut UK living costs more than new oilfields, study suggests 4 weeks ago:
It does, and it’s one of the reasons GDP is a dumb measure for quality of life. One of the primary factors for measuring GDP is consumption, so if as a society you start growing more food locally, sharing childcare among family, or just choose to repair what’s broken rather than buy more plastic crap, your GDP craters in the face of all of these.
- Comment on Heat pumps and insulation would cut UK living costs more than new oilfields, study suggests 4 weeks ago:
You’re ignoring the GDP effects of constant consumption in the form of gas. GDP is not a measure of quality of life, let alone a good economy. It goes down as you reduce consumption.
Heat pumps are a one time, up front cost, and their installation & maintenance is minor compared to the massive, 24hour spend on running a fossil economy.
- Comment on Heat pumps and insulation would cut UK living costs more than new oilfields, study suggests 4 weeks ago:
To be fair, I say this not to demotivate you, but to point out that the problem isn’t innovation, or money, or as many in this country seem to think, immigrants. It’s not even landlords.
The problem is that we’ve organised our society around the wrong incentives. If we’re serious about fixing this problem (and I think your “NIS” is a great idea!) we have to approach it with the understanding that building an NIS must that with abandoning out bad models and ridiculing those that insist it can be done with the existing system.
We don’t need a communist revolution, but we do need to be honest about Why We Can’t Have Nice Things and begin the work of building systems that allow for them while dismantling ones that prevent them.
- Comment on Heat pumps and insulation would cut UK living costs more than new oilfields, study suggests 4 weeks ago:
I love it. It makes sense if your goal is to improve the lives of the public and save money long term.
What it doesn’t do is improve GDP (this would actually have a negative effect) or enrich more billionaires. That sort of thing doesn’t tend to play well in this country.
- Comment on [Video] Labour party demands everyone to testify Zionism is not racism, or they will refuse to work with them Sky News Panel finds it funny 4 weeks ago:
Weird strategy. All this does is give oxygen to the the ZiR policy and by extension legitimise the Green position. I expected Labour to be smarter than that, but I’ll take it.
- Comment on [Video] BBC journalist loads an entire bookshelf of Zionist propaganda in his question to Zack Polanski 5 weeks ago:
At this point, I think Polanski might get more milage out of just saying: “No. No country has that right, and if they’re going to insist on genocide as a solution to their problems, I can’t understand why you insist on defending them.”
It’d to piss off the Israel fanatics, but they’re never going to support the Greens anyway. It would however take this question off the table theoretically.
- Comment on I won't accept exclusion within Green Party, says Polanski after criticism of Zionism motion 1 month ago:
It’s controversial by definition. It’s sewing controversy. In the party, in the media, and in the broader public. To pretend otherwise is to live in a world without facts.
And I don’t know what you’re on about regarding my “treats”. You and I share the same goal: liberation of the Palestinian people, but while you’re content to derail any progress we might have made on that front in an effort to “cleanse” the party, I’d rather we find a way to do something for them. Nice use of the word “cleanse” there, very inclusive. I’m sure the people who still associate Zionism with Judaism and fear another Holocaust would absolutely love to be part of a party with people using that sort of language.
This isn’t a conversation that’s going to be productive (much like every other conversation around this over the next 6-12 months) so I’m tapping out. You should come back to this in a year though and ask yourself just what this stunt has wrought and how we might have better served Palestine with that time if only we hadn’t been obsessed with tightening the noose of virtue around each other.
- Comment on I won't accept exclusion within Green Party, says Polanski after criticism of Zionism motion 1 month ago:
Of course I agree with the motion. I’m a thinking person with a reasonable understanding of the history of the region. I’m assuming you are too, but I hate to break it to you, you aren’t most people.
Most people don’t understand that Zionism ≠ Judaism and this motion will absolutely not help in their education. It will alienate them, and the media will have more ammo to paint us with the “extreme crazies” brush. Worse still, people within the party who have joined, perhaps even as their first foray into politics are going to feel alienated. The party will appear to have been co-opted by a bunch of masturbatory academics, bent on spending time and resources defining a word that has no effect other than to piss people off an alienate them. Indeed that’s all the party’s been talking about over the last few days: the fact that this motion is meaningless. So what have we accomplished exactly?
This is a classic case of the Left’s favourite pastime: purity tests and virtue signalling. Now everyone who pushed for this meaningless exercise can pat themselves on the back for being enlightened and they can look down on everyone who opposed it, abstained, or dared to clarify its meaning as Polanski has done here. Then, when the taste of that passes, they can get back to sabotaging any real work (which requires cooperation, something these people cannot understand) by choosing a new group of people to alienate.
Next up: the meat-eaters. It’s bad for the animals and the environment. Fuck those guys. Let’s pass a motion declaring meat-eating evil. Actually, that’s not good enough. Roll the pansy-assed vegetarians in there because they lack the conviction of proper vegans.
This is what this sort of politics breeds, and it doesn’t stop until you have a party of just 8 people who think they’re better than everyone else while giving the other 7 the side-eye.
Politics is about community and working with others — others who may not agree with you on everything, who may not have made the same journey you have (yet?) to come to the same conclusions, but you have enough in common to pull together to get things done. These people have done the opposite. They’ve driven a wedge into the party for zero benefit, to (as you say) “filter out” people they don’t like. Palestinians won’t benefit from a bunch of Britons defining a word. They would have benefitted from the blockage of arms sales to Israel, but they’ve set back any progress we could have possibly had on that now.
It’s just so dumb, and selfish, and navel-gazing. And the reaction here to Polanski, rejecting him if he should dare do anything other than to embrace this idiot motion… it’s just so counterproductive.
- Comment on I won't accept exclusion within Green Party, says Polanski after criticism of Zionism motion 1 month ago:
How though? You can still accept that Zionism is racism (it is) and make the statements he has here. If the contention is that Zionist == Jew, then that would lead to the exclusion of some people based on religious belief, but as Zionism and Judaism are distinct ideas, nothing he said here is unreasonable. He wouldn’t have to say anything if this dumb motion hadn’t been brought to a vote in the first place.
This motion was toxic af to the entire party and if I didn’t know better I’d think it was designed to be just that. It offers no tangible benefit to the party, nor to anyone on the planet, especially Palestinians who might have benefited from having a party with stated goals of their liberation with some power in the UK. Now we have to spend the next year or so digging into the academic weeds with the public explaining just what Zionism is, why we oppose it, and how the policy is effectively meaningless as it excludes no one, but for some reason a bunch of ideological puritans insisted that this be the thing we’re all talking about. Not climate change, not wealth disparity, and certainly not the plight of the Palestinians.
It’s absolutely absurd how the Left is so hell-bent on destroying itself with purity tests and virtue signalling.
- Comment on Green Party members to vote on declaring Zionism a form of racism at conference 1 month ago:
Welcome to the team!
- Comment on Israel bans Zack Polanski after Green Party backs 'Zionism is racism' motion 1 month ago:
I’m sure he’s really broken up about that /s.
- Comment on [Video] Green Party defends their Zionism is Racism motion on GBNews 1 month ago:
It’s not the best defence of the policy that could have been made, but frankly the fact that GBNews even allowed him to talk about it rather than shouting over him is better than I’ve seen from other outlets.
- Comment on Britain’s second richest person leaves UK for Monaco 1 month ago:
Oh no! Anyway…
- Comment on Green Party members to vote on declaring Zionism a form of racism at conference 1 month ago:
It’s absolutely racism, but I fail to see how defining a word is something that needs a vote within a political party. It sounds like a great way to sew division in a time when having everyone just agree to oppose genocide is hard enough.
- Comment on Half of Reform voters think Britain should have closer ties to the EU, poll shows 1 month ago:
Asset in partnership, absolutely, but there’s a sizable chunk of this country sees treating other nations as equals as “losing”.
- Comment on Analysis: EVs are now nine times cheaper than petrol or diesel to drive in UK 1 month ago:
E-bikes are many times cheaper than both!
- Comment on Half of Reform voters think Britain should have closer ties to the EU, poll shows 1 month ago:
They suffer under the illusion that the UK is somehow better than all EU nations and should therefore have a stronger relationship as the dominant party. They sit there and imagine the UK saying to the continent:
“You will give us all your good stuff, allow us to holiday on your beaches, and in return we will grace you with our presence when we feel like it.”
It’s utterly delusional of course, but Reform is not a party of facts.
- Comment on UK's 'dismal' Eurovision song choices to be examined by MPs 1 month ago:
Brits need to chill the fuck out when it comes to Eurovision. It’s a contest where you’re judged by the community, so when you’re routinely dicks to your neighbours you’re gonna lose… a lot. It has very little to do with the act on stage.
- Comment on Government makes £5bn a year from immigration fees while applicants are forced into debt 2 months ago:
Yeah the fees are no joke. Moving here 10 years ago the fees came to around €5k the first year and there were additional exorbitant fees at the 2.5 year and 5 year mark. I can only assume the rates are higher now.
Another fun fact about the process is that the forms they ask you to fill out are intentionally hard to understand and surrounded by warnings that your application will be auto-rejected if even one field is wrong. They then direct you to a list of private companies that claim to fill out the application for you, to avoid such a negative outcome.
Everyone comes away from this process with the understanding that it’s a scam designed to enrich some a bunch of companies.
- Comment on [Video] People Against Genocide target DSV's logistics office in Bristol. DSV transport parts and weapons for Israel's biggest arms firm, Elbit Systems. 2 months ago:
The red paint is nice and all, but hardly puts a dent in their business and puts the “vandals” at risk of being arrested for terrorism.
If they’re willing to take that risk, I don’t understand why they don’t target Elbit’s ability to move their weapons. A bunch of flat truck tires would have a greater effect than a few broken windows and some paint.
- Comment on [Video] Woman assaulted after heckling Nigel Farage at his conference 2 months ago:
…and for holding up paper signs.
- Comment on What happened to Sangita Myska, LBC - Count Binface 2 months ago:
I also had to look her up on Wikipedia, but then went one step further and found the interview that seems to have gotten her blackballed: www.youtube.com/watch?v=v5i7NEjBQks
Honestly, it’s pretty tame, and her questions are quite reasonable… so of course they had to kick her.
- Comment on Zack Polanski says he'll run for former PM Starmer's seat in by-election 2 months ago:
Godspeed sir!
- Comment on New 'Star Trek' Movie Writers Tease "Dark" Story And New Franchise 2 months ago:
They really are determined to undermine Star Trek.
- Comment on They’re Smearing Zack Polanski. Here’s Why 2 months ago:
We all knew that this was coming, that the British press would absolutely smear a party leader as antisemitic if he dared defend Palestinians. I’m not surprised, but I am frustrated. We need a better strategy to reach the public because the media is clearly acting as gatekeepers and has its own agenda.
The typical answer to this is lately been: “Just leverage social media! It worked for Trump!” but this ignores the fact that legacy media has played a critical role there, amplifying his message and creating stories from that manchild’s tweets. The Greens are never going to get that level of special treatment unless it’s to destroy us.
- Comment on Number of children injured in e-scooter crashes in England surges 2 months ago:
There are some serious gaps in the article around what the riders were colliding with. The only detailed account was with a car, in which (surprise surprise) the scooter rider was the one penalised.
These scooters are new, but that doesn’t make them a bad idea. I see parents using them to drop off their lids at school every day for example. Every person you see on a scooter is someone who would otherwise be in front of you in a car.
If we’re really concerned about the health and safety of kids riding these things, we should:
- reduce/remove car traffic
- patch potholes