A fully automated, on demand, personalized con man, ready to lie to you about any topic you want doesn’t really seem like an ideal product. I don’t think that’s what the developers of these LLMs set out to make when they created them either. However, I’ve seen this behavior to a certain extent in every LLM I’ve interacted with. One of my favorite examples was a particularly small-parameter version of Llama (I believe it was Llama-3.1-8B) confidently insisting to me that Walt Disney invented the Matterhorn (like, the actual mountain) for Disneyland. Now, this is something along the lines of what people have been calling “hallucinations” in LLMs, but the fact that it would not admit that it was wrong when confronted and used confident language to try to convince me that it was right, is what pushes that particular case across the boundary to what I would call “con-behavior”. Assertiveness is not always a property of this behavior, though. Lately, OpenAI (and I’m sure other developers) have been training their LLMs to be more “agreeable” and to acquiesce to the user more often. This doesn’t eliminate this con-behavior, though. I’d like to show you another example of this con-behavior that is much more problematic.
an llm is a cool way to rephrase your own thoughts back at you. it’s pretty useful for brainstorming. or masturbation. i sure hope that’s all anyone uses it for
floofloof@lemmy.ca 1 day ago
And it’s promoted by business people with the exact same skill set. I would argue though that there’s nothing wrong with what LLMs are doing: they’re doing what they were trained to do. The con is in how it’s being sold to us as a source of knowledge or understanding akin to a search engine.
cecilkorik@lemmy.ca 1 day ago
Ironically I do believe AI would make a great CEO/business person. What’s horrifying about that is no matter how dystopian our situation now is, a planet run by corporations run by incompetent but brutally efficient AI CEOs seems certain to become even more dystopian.
laranis@lemmy.zip 1 day ago
So are all the leaders at my company.
Confidence is promoted over competence every time.