Comment on Not likely to be AI-generated or Deepfake
vithigar@lemmy.ca 3 weeks agoIt is absolutely not true of all AI images. I’d be surprised if it’s even true about most AI images.
Comment on Not likely to be AI-generated or Deepfake
vithigar@lemmy.ca 3 weeks agoIt is absolutely not true of all AI images. I’d be surprised if it’s even true about most AI images.
Krauerking@lemy.lol 3 weeks ago
Just saying that because you feel like it’s true or because you’ve participated in that line of thought for even 5 seconds?
AI images come from a noise map, it’s true cause they generate from it in a consistent manner.
vithigar@lemmy.ca 3 weeks ago
I’m saying it because it’s not only obvious with even a moments thought (you can literally just ask it for an entirely red image or whatever), but also because it’s easily provable.
Prompt: “Under the sea”
Image:
Image
Average pixel colour:
Image
Prompt: “a man with red hair wearing a red coat standing in front of a red background”
Image:
Image
Average pixel colour:
Image
So I ask you the same question. Did you just say that because you felt like it was true?
Krauerking@lemy.lol 3 weeks ago
The average brightness values of those are both middle of the road grey. Sorry I should have rephrased as I misspoke calling it beige but the point still stands that has the most average toned color.
If you look they are middling around 50-60% where as a similar red photo intake would likely have a higher contrast and an average color with a higher brightness.
vithigar@lemmy.ca 3 weeks ago
I’d expect that many images are going to be somewhere near 50% grey if you average their luminance out overall. That’s just the average of every colour though. The fact that averaging a range of things tends toward a standard distribution isn’t particularly surprising. Again though, it’s not hard to get a diffusion model to generate something outside of that expectation.
Prompt: “night sky”
Image:
Image
Average colour:
Image
Average brightness: 21%
Prompt: “lineless image of an old man drawn in yellow ink on white background”
Image:
Image
Average colour:
Image
Average brightness: 90%