Comment on Nobel Prize 2024

<- View Parent
GreenKnight23@lemmy.world ⁨2⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

those aren’t examples they’re hearsay. “oh everybody knows this to be true”

You are ignoring ALL of the of the positive applications of AI from several decades of development, and only focusing on the negative aspects of generative AI.

generative AI is the only “AI”. everything that came before that was a thought experiment based on the human perception of a neural network. it’d be like calling a first draft a finished book.

if you consider the Turing Test AI then it blurs the line between a neural net and nested if/else logic.

Here is a non-exhaustive list of some applications:

  • In healthcare as a tool for earlier detection and prevention of certain diseases

great, give an example of this being used to save lives from a peer reviewed source that won’t be biased by product development or hospital marketing.

  • For anomaly detection in intrusion detection system, protecting web servers

let’s be real here, this is still a golden turd and is more ML than AI. I know because it’s my job to know.

hearsay, give a creditable source of when this was used to save lives. I doubt that AI could ever be used in this way because it’s basic disaster triage, which would open ANY company up to litigation should their algorithm kill someone.

this dumb. AI isn’t even used in this and you know it. algorithms are not AI. falls are detected when a sudden gyroscopic speed/ direction is identified based on a set number of variables. everyone falls the same when your phone is in your pocket. dropping your phone will show differently due to a change in mass and spin. again, algorithmic not AI.

forecasting is an algorithm not AI. ML would determine the percentage of an algorithm is accurate based on what it knows. algorithms and ML is not AI.

There have even been a lot of good applications of generative AI, e.g. in production, especially for construction, where a generative AI can the functionally same product but with less material, while still maintaining the strength. This reduces cost of manufacturing, and also the environmental impact due to the reduced material usage.

this reads just like the marketing bullshit companies promote to show how “altruistic” they are.

Does AI have its problems? Sure. Is generative AI being misused and abused? Definitely. But just because some applications are useless it doesn’t mean that the whole field is.

I won’t deny there is potential there, but we’re a loooong way from meaningful impact.

A hammer can be used to murder someone, that does not mean that all hammers are murder weapons.

just because a hammer is a hammer doesn’t mean it can’t be used to commit murder. dumbest argument ever, right up there with “only way to stop a bad guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun.”

source
Sort:hotnewtop