I think that scene in Uncharted did try to handwave that none of the museum guards are being killed - Nate is using a tranq gun, and the one guy who gets pulled into the ocean, they make an offhand remark that he’ll be able to swim to shore. But yeah, it’s doomed by the trappings of gameplay systems meant for gunning down tons of mercs.
Comment on GTA 6 Will Encourage Empathy, Rockstar Says
Dariusmiles2123@piefed.social 1 day ago
The fact that you’re a criminal who kills people without counting is what’s drawing me away from GTA games now.
I hate the fact that in so many games, even ones where you’re a good guy, it’s okay to kill innocents.
I don’t know if it was in Uncharted 2 or 3, but at one point you’re on top of a museum and you have to kill a guard who’s just doing his duty and wants to go back to his family after. It was really difficult for me to go back to the game afterward.
GTA is clearly different, but I can’t have empathy with characters who have none..
In GTAV these guys where killing many cops and just going back to a normal family life where you’re supposed to feel sorry for the guy because his wife is cheating on him.
I have no problems with killing bad guys in games but I hate it when you’re forced to kill cops or security guards without having any other choice and without consequences on your morality.
Katana314@lemmy.world 1 day ago
Dariusmiles2123@piefed.social 1 day ago
Oh I don’t remember the remark about the guard being able to swim. Maybe it was an update or I missed it.
But, still, I wish video games were better at making you avoid hurting innocents.
To be honest, movies, even ones about criminals, are better at this or they are at least making you feel that what’s happening is wrong.
socsa@piefed.social 1 day ago
But GTA historically plays like pastiche of the genre. The casual treatment of mass murder and extreme violence is meant to be part of the satire. The most recent games are not really subtle about it either, often openly telling jokes about the absurdity of the scenarios it puts the player in.
IMO, that’s a big part of why it works, and why games like RDR and Uncharted feel so hollow in comparison - because they are trying to take themselves seriously as art without that levity. Just in general, this is why satire is such a powerful narrative tool. There’s a lot of good philosophy which can be captured in the comedic irony of subverted expectations.
Nola@piefed.zip 1 day ago
One of the meta narratives in The Last of Us 2 was conceived directly around confronting this notion.
Which is one reason why I still consider it a masterpiece on many levels.
Dariusmiles2123@piefed.social 1 day ago
For me it’s probably the greatest game ever.
I loved how it made you understand that the other side isn’t necessary a bad side.
I don’t know if we will or should get a third one, but I really loved it.
Every NPC had a name and history and you can hear their friends hurting when you kill them.
The game was really moving abd made me think about deeper stuff a lot.
ampersandrew@lemmy.world 1 day ago
Have you played GTA4? I’m not going to say there’s zero ludonarrative dissonance, and you definitely kill plenty of cops, but that game’s story is very much about how people can get stuck in cycles of recidivism.
Dariusmiles2123@piefed.social 1 day ago
Yeah and I loved it! But I was younger and Nico was not portrayed as a nice family guy so it bothered me less.
For me Nico was some kind of war criminal on the run and he had a bad guy’s face.
He wasn’t the friendly black guy from Watch Dogs 2.