By this logic you could also ban Photoshop, tablets and any other software or hardware tool that has improved accessibility and workflow over the years.
AI is a tool, flat out banning it won’t and can’t work. It’s too fucking useful.
People said that anyone who used Photoshop wasn’t a real artist, people said computer graphics weren’t real art.
At some point you DO have to draw an arbitrary line. Because that’s all. Art is arbitrary all of it since the dawn of mankind making art. It’s all arbitrary. If you only make hard lines that completely block tools, all you’re doing is harming artists.
The entire point of drawing arbitrary lines is to allow for artists to keep making art. Why dissuading people from abusing others.
So do you want no one to be able to do anything or do you want things to actually have artistic expression which is arbitrary.
brucethemoose@lemmy.world 11 hours ago
Then you’re going to get no games.
Or just get devs lying about using cursor or whatever when they code.
warm@kbin.earth 11 hours ago
How have we all forgotten that games were made perfectly fine for decades without AI? Better games even.
I'd rather give an award to a "worse" game that didnt use AI, than to a game that did.
Devs can lie, but the truth always comes out eventually.
kogasa@programming.dev 10 hours ago
“the truth” being that a few generated placeholder textures were accidentally left in and promptly replaced? crazy
warm@kbin.earth 3 hours ago
Why didnt they just buy placeholder textures?
brucethemoose@lemmy.world 11 hours ago
Then most just won’t go on the Game Awards, and devs will go on using Cursor or whatever they feel comfortable with in their IDE setup.
I’m all against AI slop, but you’re setting an unreasonably absolute standard. It’s like saying “I will never use any game that was developed in proximity to any closed source software.” That is possible, technically, but most people aren’t gonna do that. It’s basically impossible on a larger team. Give them some slack with the requirement; it’s okay to develop on Windows or on Steam, just open the game’s source.
Similarly, let devs use basic tools. Ban slop from the end product.
warm@kbin.earth 3 hours ago
Cool, dont accept awards then. Its not the be all and end all.
lepinkainen@lemmy.world 9 hours ago
Games were made by a single person not sleeping for a week.
But people expect more now and one person can’t do it fueled just by passion. The other people want to get paid now, not when the game is released.
Limiting the tools people can use to make games is ableist, elitist and just stupid.
vxx@lemmy.world 8 hours ago
Theyre not limiting their tools, they’re limiting some awards they could win when they created real art.