Comment

Comment on Dude read the rules of woman only community and decided to post anyway

brucethemoose@lemmy.world ⁨6⁩ ⁨hours⁩ ago

To correct your ‘public park’ analogy, the space is public. Men can wander in. But it has clear signs posted at the only entrance saying its a space for women to speak, please be quiet, otherwise.

If you wander in and violate that rule, that is no one’s fault but yours.

personally i have a dick but i don’t really identify as being a ‘man’. nor do identify as being a ‘woman’. i’m just a person. so am i therefore allowed to commentate? or is the mods who determine my sex/gender status, regardless of how i perceive myself?

…A primary reason for that rule is basically “don’t be a dick about this being a women’s only space, please.”

If you feel you qualify as a woman to speak in the space, go for it! That’s the idea. But you specifically say "nor do [I] identify as being a ‘woman’. "

But making an issue out of it is exactly what is unwanted.

source

Sort:hotnew top

TubularTittyFrog@lemmy.world ⁨5⁩ ⁨hours⁩ ago
just because i feel that way doesn’t mean the people in charge feel that way.

source
- brucethemoose@lemmy.world ⁨4⁩ ⁨hours⁩ ago
  I’m not trying to grandstand. My issue is with these presumptions:
  
  like if the mods want to auto-ban everyone who doesn’t personally verify with them their womanhood, that’s their business. but expecting people to self-police their gender is a dumb expectation.
  
  They’re not checking you at the door. They aren’t auto banning anyone. They very politely point out the sidebar to a few posters, then request them to stay quiet; that’s the extent of it.
  
  …If you don’t make an issue of that, it’s not an issue.
  
  if you want a private exclusive type of space… then make it private and exclusive. that way you can control who views and interacts with the event and even hire security to keep the ‘wrong’ people out.
  
  But this is unrealistic, as then they wouldn’t get nearly as much participation in the space. It’s a public gathering spot, by choice.
  
  Again, my specific problem is with poster the mods point out the rules to, yet willingly choose to ignore them.
  
  Just because you think rules are unrealistic does not give you a right to ignore them once asked. That’s how every community here works. Yet they seem to get tons of posters carrying that attitude.
  
  That’s what makes me bristle. Respecting community rules (once known) is basic human civility, and people are perfectly capable of ‘self-policing’ that. I do not like the rejection of that, and the policing of others in its place.
  
  source