Comment on America's Smartest Man Finds Something Interesting
Objection@lemmy.ml 3 months agoI thought critically about the issue and came to the conclusion that genocide and apartheid are bad and that fascism is wrong. Not my fault if enough other people reach the same conclusion for it to be trendy.
Neon@lemmy.world 3 months ago
no, you did not think critically about this Issue.
Because this Issue never was about genocide or apartheid or fascism. You thought about something entirely else.
You thought that “he has a Flag I don’t like, so I will discard his opinion on any matter”
Hardly critical or even smart thinking, is it?
Objection@lemmy.ml 3 months ago
It’s kind of impressive how many wrong things you just said.
First, it is valid to disregard someone’s opinions based on their other political views. If you had a swastika in your username, should I ignore that and listen earnestly to everything you say? Of course not.
Second, this is about fascism because the quoted text in OP is fascist propaganda. What they’re describing is the idea of the ubermensch, of certain people being inherently superior and genetically predisposed to rule over others.
Third, you’re not a mind reader. You’re incorrectly assuming that you know my thought process. I did not think, “This person has an Israeli flag, therefore they must be wrong,” I thought, “This person is telling people to look for a point in what is very clearly fascist propaganda, hey, look at that, they also have a fascist flag in their username, I guess it makes sense that they’d do that.”
So no, I didn’t write off your opinion because of you support of a fascist regime, though if I had it would’ve been valid. I simply thought critically about two different behaviors you did and noticed that they both display sympathy towards fascism, which I found interesting.
karobeccary@lemmy.world 1 month ago
“Noooooo it’s not critical thinking unless you agree with meeee!”
This fuckin guy.
Israel is an apartheid state engaging in genocide.