I mean, why wouldn’t we just ban smartphones for everyone then?
Comment on Why are US states, school districts banning smartphones in schools?
blindsight@beehaw.org 4 months agoAs an educator and parent, I couldn’t disagree more strongly. Smart phones are addiction machines and childhood experience blockers. Children should not have smart phones at all until age 16. Age 16 would be a very appropriate time to introduce smart phones after their harms have been explained in detail at ages 12 through 15.
Banning cell phones during instructional time doesn’t go far enough. Students having a smart phone in their pocket is damaging. (Dumb phones are fine—SMS texting and phone calls are great.)
There has been a precipitous decline in youth mental health globally in nations where cell phones were affordable starting in 2010. The evidence is clear. Smart phones (and, more broadly, addictive dark patterns in all apps/games) are a big problem.
If you want to learn more, read the first chapter of The Anxious Generation by Jonathan Haidt. (I’d recommend the full book if you want details, but chapter 1 is enough to give you a grounding in the data and the broad strokes of the argument.)
match@pawb.social 4 months ago
blindsight@beehaw.org 4 months ago
By age 16, there’s reason to think that youth can handle the addictive nature of what phones, with support. Same for adults.
That said, yes, we probably should make dark patterns illegal, in general.
t3rmit3@beehaw.org 4 months ago
Out of curiosity, (given that in another comment you talked about home schooling) when you call yourself an educator, do you have a teaching certificate in your state?
blindsight@beehaw.org 4 months ago
I’m certified to teach in my jurisdiction. I have a teaching degree, and I have completed additional professional training specific to this topic through conferences, books, and other professional development (PD).
I can’t source conference talks or teacher PD groups, so I sourced a popular press book that’s approachable to laymen.
t3rmit3@beehaw.org 4 months ago
Awesome, thank you.
ShepherdPie@midwest.social 4 months ago
“My jurisdiction” could mean their house and their degree could be from PragerU or some other sham online college. The way everything is worded so vaguely leads me to believe this is the case.