Comment

Comment on Are We Watching The Internet Die?

Unlike the author, I don’t think that the internet is dying, but instead entering a new phase that resembles in some aspects the old internet: search has become unreliable and those mega-platforms enshittify themselves to death, so people shift to smaller (often non-commercial) platforms and find new content to follow by the hyperlinks provided by other people. It’s a lot like the internet before Google Search.

It is definitely feeling like this is a trend, we are moving back to more curated ways of sharing information.

The Fediverse feels like a return to the old, open Web before it was captured by Big Tech, just with new bells and whistles attached. With all the enshittification, it seems like it is well-placed to be the solution to the problem. It’s not there yet but it’s a start.

source

Sort:hotnew top

lvxferre@mander.xyz ⁨9⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
Let’s hope that the new bells and whistles* increase its resilience enough against Big Tech control over the internet. Otherwise we’ll get into a cyclical situation.

*namely, federation and other anti-centralisation aspects of design.

source
- supersquirrel@sopuli.xyz ⁨9⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
  The aspect that makes the fediverse and in particular reddit-likes uniquely adapted to growing in this harsh corporate hellscape has everything in my opinion to do with the critical early seed phase of communities.
  
  When you make a website with its own forum, you have huge friction to overcome with the network effect… but if you are plugging into a federated network than all of a sudden being a tiny community on lemmy with 2 or 3 people becomes an invitation to users passing by who already have an account to start a conversation and create that spark that will grow (slowly) into a real community.
  
  Consider the minimum viable population of users in a community, how many people does there need to be in a room before that warm feeling of a gathering sets in with comfortable conversation naturally occurring? For federated lemmy communities (and similar Reddit-likes) federation effectively lowers that number by a significant amount since it puts doors everywhere that people can spontaneously wander through and contribute small amounts to help kindle a spark and get the community going.
  
  This changes the paradigm of “social media platform metabolism” if you will, it facilitates much more organic early growth in communities.
  
  source
  - lvxferre@mander.xyz ⁨9⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
    Yup - federated communities grow specially well in a corporate landscape. However my concern is if they’re able to stay dominant enough to prevent a cycle like:
    
    Corporate landscape.
    
    You got a few federated alternatives growing.
    
    Federations grow enough to become the main landscape.
    
    Corporations do something [I do not know what] better than federations.
    
    Corporates grow to the point of dwarfing the federations, into a corporate landscape.
    
    For example, it’s possible for me that corporations are specially able to exploit a federated landscape through EEE. I’m just conjecturing though.
    
    source