Comment on Are we finally ready to reopen all the Nut Houses
Warl0k3@lemmy.world 1 day agoI’m glad you’ve engaged with the subject since your last comment! However I should clarify something - I pointed out the “explicitly contradicted by the very first sentence of the wikipedia article” thing not because I thought that in itself it refuted the point that you were trying to make (which was admittedly unclear), but to maybe hint that your understanding of Kant’s work is, just perhaps, slightly flawed.
I did puzzle over it for a bit though and (please correct me if I’m wrong) I think what you’re trying to argue is roughly this:
The 1st formula says we should only act according to behaviors governed by rules everyone can follow. So, if we look at the behavior here [that a man wants to marry a realdoll], and then imagine what would happen if everyone followed that rule, it would end in disaster because there would be no more procreation.
Is that an accurate interpretation?
wowwoweowza@lemmy.world 22 hours ago
Kant doesn’t use “if”, he uses “must.” So… envision what happens if all men must marry real dolls.
And I concede… Kant is extraordinarily deep and moral philosophy is challenging.
I just like to explore or apply the categorical imperative as a thought experiment some times.