Comment on The brightest minds
5318008@lemmy.ml 1 day agoI am eating a slice of pizza at the finish line, waiting for you to catch up to me.
It would be strange for you to say “we are eating pizza” if I am not also eating pizza.
It would also be strange for you to say “we discussed this” if you had discussed it, but I had not.
It would also be strange for you to say “we unpacked this topic” if you had formalized the topic, and I had not.
Do you agree?
petrol_sniff_king@lemmy.blahaj.zone 1 day ago
I haven’t said anything about us unpacking it. I have though.
5318008@lemmy.ml 1 day ago
It would be strange for **a person ** to say “we unpacked this topic” if you had formalized the topic, and I had not.
Do you agree?
petrol_sniff_king@lemmy.blahaj.zone 1 day ago
But I’m not saying “we” have unpacked this. I agree, that would be strange.
5318008@lemmy.ml 1 day ago
Good, thank you. I’m A and you’re B. In this very typical usage, “We” equals “A and B”. As in, “We unpacked this” equals “A and B unpacked this”. You agree that this is the typical interpretation, here.
“A has not unpacked this” ⇒ “A has not unpacked this” or “B has not unpacked this” ⇔ not “A has unpacked this” or not “B has unpacked this” ⇔ not(“A has unpacked this” and “B has unpacked this”)(De Morgan) ⇔ not “A and B have unpacked this” ⇔ not “We have unpacked this” ⇔ “We have not unpacked this”
Then we conclude “A has not unpacked this” ⇒ “We have not unpacked this”, and so it is simply more specific. It is not possible for “We have not unpacked this” to be incorrect at the same time that “A has not unpacked this” is correct.