Comment on The brightest minds

<- View Parent
5318008@lemmy.ml ⁨1⁩ ⁨day⁩ ago

Good, thank you. I’m A and you’re B. In this very typical usage, “We” equals “A and B”. As in, “We unpacked this” equals “A and B unpacked this”. You agree that this is the typical interpretation, here.

“A has not unpacked this” ⇒ “A has not unpacked this” or “B has not unpacked this” ⇔ not “A has unpacked this” or not “B has unpacked this” ⇔ not(“A has unpacked this” and “B has unpacked this”)(De Morgan) ⇔ not “A and B have unpacked this” ⇔ not “We have unpacked this” ⇔ “We have not unpacked this”

Then we conclude “A has not unpacked this” ⇒ “We have not unpacked this”, and so it is simply more specific. It is not possible for “We have not unpacked this” to be incorrect at the same time that “A has not unpacked this” is correct.

source
Sort:hotnewtop