A game like that doesn’t get released without playtesting. They playtested. Maybe the way they did it was flawed, but it happened.
Comment on Take-Two’s Firaxis, Maker of ‘Civilization,’ Cuts a Third of Its Staff
scrubbles@poptalk.scrubbles.tech 4 hours ago
Civ 7 had such promise. Everything was gorgeous, good strategy, but such weird systems they clearly didn’t playtest with people. Like switching leaders 1/3 is interesting, but they never mentioned you’d lose access to everything you built so far and it’d be like starting over again. Just super weird, I was disappointed.
They also tried to make it more inclusive for more people, easier to get into, which just made diehard longtime fans more annoyed by it. I find myself going back to Civ 5 regularly, 6 and 7 not so much.
ampersandrew@lemmy.world 4 hours ago
scrubbles@poptalk.scrubbles.tech 4 hours ago
Fair, let me rephrase. I’m sure the issues were brought up, but in modern game studios going against a core feature like the age system and saying “It’s annoying” or suggesting it should be scrapped would be a career killer, and it enforces hiding feedback.
ampersandrew@lemmy.world 4 hours ago
They said outwardly exactly which problem they were trying to solve with this design: snowballing. When a game of Civ goes on so long, the winner could have been decided early on in a game that has hours and hours left. But it does sound like their solution came at too great of a cost to other things.
klankin@piefed.ca 3 hours ago
I heard they were also had a philosophy of something like each game should take a third from the old, improve a third, and entirely write the last third new.
Cool idea to ensure the games stay fresh, but really by game 7 that was just going to piss fans off.
Jaderick@lemmy.world 4 hours ago
I’ll die on the hill that Civ 6 is better than 5, but I lost interest in 7 really fast. I like the option to change civs dependent on achievements throughout the game, but the near hard reset per age change was too jarring to be fun.
cenotaph@piefed.zip 19 minutes ago
With you on that one. Civ VI without DLC, V is better. With DLC? Civ VI for sure