Comment on OpenAI says it’s “impossible” to create useful AI models without copyrighted material
hascat@programming.dev 5 months agoThat’s not the point though. The point is that the human comedian and the AI both benefit from consuming creative works covered by copyright.
And human comedians regularly get called out when they outright steal others material and present it as their own.
The word for this is plagiarism.
And in OpenAIs framework, when used in a relevant commercial context, they are functionally operating at profiting off of the worlds most comprehensive plagiarism software.
They get called out when they use others work as a template, not as training data.
Phanatik@kbin.social 5 months ago
Yeah except a machine is owned by a company and doesn't consume the same way. It breaks down copyrighted works into data points so it can find the best way of putting those data points together again. If you understand anything at all about how these models work, they do not consume media the same way we do. It is not an entity with a thought process or consciousness (despite the misleading marketing of "AI" would have you believe), it's an optimisation algorithm.
chahk@beehaw.org 5 months ago
It’s a glorified autocomplete.
Phanatik@kbin.social 5 months ago
It's so funny that this is something new. This was Grammarly's whole schtick since before ChatGPT so how different is Grammarly AI?
vexikron@lemmy.zip 5 months ago
Here is the bigger picture: The vast majority of tech illiterate people think something is AI because duh its called AI.
Its literally just the power of branding and marketing on the minds of poorly informed humans.
Unfortunately this is essentially a reverse Turing Test.
The vast majority of humans do not know anything about AI, and also a huge majority of them can also barely tell the difference between, currently in some but not all forms, output from what is basically a brute force total internet plagiarism and synthesis software, from many actual human created content in many cases.
To me this basically just means that about 99% of the time, most humans are actually literally NPCs, and they only do actual creative and unpredictable things very very rarely.