Especially in a creative company like ours, the best ideas come from people in the same room, sharing perspectives, challenging one another and solving problems.

Strong disagree. That might be the best way to avoid the worst idea, but it’s not the best way for creative people to have an original vision.

Swat down a bad idea and it either lives or dies on merit. Swat down an interesting creative vision, and it often becomes secret/internal/personal.