If you’re running NVME or SSD, you don’t have to worry about fragmentation at all and neither will NTFS or Windows.
On rotational media, recent versions of windows do it when it needs it. NTFS itself has become better about not splitting up files when there’s contiguous space available.
Defrag is usually only for drives that are written to and data deleted often, creating gaps. If it’s just storage, probably ok. I’ve got 4x 20 drives in my truenas, but it’s zfs, from what I’ve read, can’t or don’t need to defrag.
Need? Probably not unless they’re nearly full. Get some benefit from? at least a little. NTFS and 11 try to keep fragmentation at bay without killing your disk. New writes that won’t fit in a hole are pushed ahead of the platter until they will.
Go run optimize drives, it’ll tell you what the state is
rumba@lemmy.zip 3 weeks ago
If you’re running NVME or SSD, you don’t have to worry about fragmentation at all and neither will NTFS or Windows.
On rotational media, recent versions of windows do it when it needs it. NTFS itself has become better about not splitting up files when there’s contiguous space available.
finallymadeanaccount@lemmy.world 3 weeks ago
I have two 10 terabyte external hard drives that go whirr (so I assume there are platters in there). Do they need a defrag? I’m running Windows 11.
thermal_shock@lemmy.world 3 weeks ago
Defrag is usually only for drives that are written to and data deleted often, creating gaps. If it’s just storage, probably ok. I’ve got 4x 20 drives in my truenas, but it’s zfs, from what I’ve read, can’t or don’t need to defrag.
rumba@lemmy.zip 3 weeks ago
Need? Probably not unless they’re nearly full. Get some benefit from? at least a little. NTFS and 11 try to keep fragmentation at bay without killing your disk. New writes that won’t fit in a hole are pushed ahead of the platter until they will.
Go run optimize drives, it’ll tell you what the state is
elevenforum.com/…/optimize-and-defragment-drives-…
finallymadeanaccount@lemmy.world 3 weeks ago
Thank you. Turns out Windows is maintaining everything and no action was needed.