Its still a substantive critique.
The medium is the message. How information is conveyed is part of the information. Employing click bait and “guache” methods is part of an “appeal to emotion,” and argument that riles up the passions instead of convincing with reason. Someone presenting information coached in tools designed to inflame or incite should indeed be suspect if they are trying to pretend to be conveying largely “neutral” information like the news.
Excrubulent@slrpnk.net 11 months ago
“The medium is the message” explains that the medium (eg: internet video) affects the message that is being created. It’s a lot more subtle than “ALL CAPS means DECEPTION”.
Also, they’re titles, not arguments. And again, it’s just capitalisation.
It is literally a superficial critique. You had to make a bunch of reaches to explain how the superficial critique could somehow become substantive, but you failed to do so.
And honestly, the real reason people like to shit on this kind of title is because it gives them a sense of superiority because they would never debase themselves with such low brow material. It’s worse than an appeal to emotion - it’s an appeal to faux intellectualism.
mosiacmango@lemm.ee 11 months ago
The medium is the message is not that cut and dry. All parts of the medium of any scope, affect what’s said.
You can believe what you like about peoples “real reasons” but i would call the above guesswork that at best, reaffirms what you think people believe, not what they actually do.
Excrubulent@slrpnk.net 11 months ago
It’s fascinating that you had nothing to say about the fact that titles aren’t arguments and that it is clearly a superficial critique.
Also, if you really think channels that do this aren’t worth paying attention to, I ask you to explain the vlogbrothers: MASSIVE Tuberculosis News
Now, maybe you won’t bother to explain them, because you think they’re not worth listening to because they CAPITALISED a word. Of course then I could tell you that they and their audience PRESSURED a pharmaceutical company into allowing their patent to lapse so millions of lives could be saved from TB.
Of course, that sentence may have been rendered unreadable to you due to the GRATUITOUS capitalisation. I apologise, because otherwise it would’ve been absolutely worth paying attention to, but now it’s rubbish.