Comment

Comment on Tankie

Yes, really! I’ve been called a tankie and a Nazi and worse. Don’t judge what a tankie or Nazi is by insults on the internet, hyperbole and bullshit rule.

Again, your definition is not the standard definition. Tankies love tanks. And Communism. And Stalin. Which is funny, because Stalin wasn’t much of a communist.

I use the standard definition, that’s it. I am not familiar with the tankies you describe, I haven’t met them… Tankies hating tanks seems wrong to me. Back in the day they loved the T-34 tank and Russia in WW2 and so on.

Where can I find YOUR definition of “tankie”, the peace loving gentle communist? Seriously

source

Sort:hotnew top

Objection@lemmy.ml ⁨2⁩ ⁨weeks⁩ ago

Don’t judge what a tankie or Nazi is by insults on the internet, hyperbole and bullshit rule.

Words are defined by common use. If the common use of the word “tankie” is to throw it at people who oppose war, then that’s what it means now. You can say it’s defined as being pro- war, but I’ve never seen it used that way.

Back in the day when word originated they loved the T-34 tank and Russia in WW2 and so on.

Well sure, WWII is basically the go-to example of a necessary and justified war. There was a time in my life when I labelled myself as a pacifist and the counter-example that everyone always brought up was WWII.

At that time, my position was that that was one exception from like 70 years ago and we shouldn’t make a rule from the exception considering how many unjustified wars have been fought since then. Now, my position is a little bit more flexible to account for that and a handful of other cases: now I say, “no war but class war,” and WWII was a class war.

However, my position hasn’t actually changed much in practice since those days. The vast majority of wars and violence are systemic and fought for bourgeois interests, so I still oppose them. Only very rarely does violence happen in the opposite direction, for example if we compare the death tolls of Luigi Mangione to Brian Thompson.

And what do you think the “tank” in “tankie” comes from?

It comes from accusing people who oppose war of supporting the other side’s tanks, as I just explained to you in my previous comment.

source
- Mulligrubs@lemmy.world ⁨1⁩ ⁨week⁩ ago
  
  Words are defined by common use. If the common use of the word “tankie” is to throw it at people who oppose war, then that’s what it means now. You can say it’s defined as being pro- war, but I’ve never seen it used that way.
  
  Indeed. And the common use of the word tankie is “authoritarian communist”
  
  Why are you using an uncommon definition?
  
  source
  - Objection@lemmy.ml ⁨1⁩ ⁨week⁩ ago
    OK, next time someone calls me a tankie, I’ll just say, “Actually, I don’t support sending tanks to Ukraine” and I’m sure that’ll clear things up and convince them I’m not a tankie.
    
    source
    Mulligrubs@lemmy.world ⁨1⁩ ⁨week⁩ ago
    Well, that’s just silly.
    
    I didn’t make the definition
    
    tankie noun A member of the Communist Party of Great Britain who slavishly followed the Kremlin line, agreeing with the crushing of revolts in Hungary and later Czechoslovakia by Soviet tanks.
    
    This was how the term was first used in the 80s. As of today, the definition has expanded to “authoritarian communists”.
    
    Nothing about peace yet, sorry.
    
    source
    -> View More Comments