Comment

It's over

We are getting closer and it makes me very sad.

There were some songs (of different genres) which I thought "huh, sounds really good" and then noticed, that it was AI (either by a disclaimer in the description, people in the comments or by the voice; the voice of AI is still fairly noticeable) and went "fuuuuuuuck, now I don't want to like it". And this annoys me, as I know it will happen more often and also that I will miss out noticing it more.
AI creations can get flooded while real creators getting drowned out (looking with much disgust at you Pixiv and DeviantArt).

But I also want to add that I am not against AI assisted music creations. But then the creator must disclose where and how much the AI was involved.

source

Sort:hotnew top

turdcollector69@lemmy.world ⁨1⁩ ⁨day⁩ ago
I refuse to consider anything AI generated to be legitimate art.

There’s nothing intentional about it, you simply give a prompt to a machine and it matches the pattern. That isn’t art just like how doing madlibs isn’t the same as writing literature.

A person using AI tools can be ok as long as it’s a human doing the overall composition.

Like using AI to make samples to use in a song is fine, using AI to generate the entire song isn’t.

source
imetators@lemmy.dbzer0.com ⁨1⁩ ⁨day⁩ ago
I found a YT channel that talks about WWI/WWII and other wars guns in quite a detail. Seems cool and all. But then I checked date of the channel created and how often they upload. 2 years old, uploads every 3 days or so. Can’t be a real person. Voice is perfect, doesn’t sound anything like AI. Footage looks legit. But I fail to believe that even a small team under 80k sub YT channel can research, compose and record a video in 3 days.

We’re cooked. We been a long way in “don’t believe anything on the internet” and now it has become “dont believe anything at all”

source
Johanno@feddit.org ⁨1⁩ ⁨day⁩ ago
I mean I don’t like the ai music but only because you can hear it.

Now I don’t want to hear anything that is similar, so music that sounds a bit like AI but isn’t is now out of the door too.

source
exasperation@lemmy.dbzer0.com ⁨1⁩ ⁨day⁩ ago

But I also want to add that I am not against AI assisted music creations.

I thought this was a great TED talk describing how AI can be used in the composition and “recording” of works where a human is still in the driver’s seat. In this person’s case, it’s still a human mostly performing and singing, but just fed through an algorithm that makes it sound like another (famous) singer.

source