Comment

Comment on Anon can't go on a field trip

Her work may not have “changed”, but many elements in retrospect have obvious bigoted undertones, whether she intended them or not. We simply weren’t looking for them as children, and didn’t notice or understand.

If you’re interested in what some of these things are, Youtuber Shaun has an excellent video going over some of them.

source

Sort:hotnew top

hitmyspot@aussie.zone ⁨4⁩ ⁨days⁩ ago
Neil Gaiman is an alleged rapist. Does that mean the sexual scenes in his books are not valid?

Horrible people is part of the human condition. Erasing them means we don’t learn from it.

We can now better recognise the problematic parts of her work to gently help kids to appreciate it. Kids won’t get the metaphors with slavery, racism, sexism that all exist with the potterverse. However, showing them these problems even in a fantastical world can help them better understand them in the real world.

Her work doesn’t become pointless just by virtue of her being horrible. For some artists, that can even be the point. Look at Joss Whedon, who was lauded for writing powerful female characters. It’s now clear he was abusive to the young women in his vicinity. Does that make Buffy less of a heroine or more?

source
- irmoz@lemmy.world ⁨3⁩ ⁨days⁩ ago
  This doesn’t really relate to what I said whatsoever, because I never said her books or pointless or that we should erase her. I also didn’t even say you’re not allowed to read to books to your kid. Just that its content isnt great, and perhaps there are much better books for kids to read, such as the ones she lifted from, like the Earthsea Cycle.
  
  source
  - hitmyspot@aussie.zone ⁨3⁩ ⁨days⁩ ago
    Your implication in the Hitler reference was that we should not appreciate art from horrible people.
    
    I’m glad my points changed your mind so much that we now agree, for the most part. ;)
    
    source
    irmoz@lemmy.world ⁨2⁩ ⁨days⁩ ago
    No, that wasn’t my implication, nor did you change my mind. I still think it would be better to be reading better art, made by better people. Doesn’t mean I’m trying to, like, ban Harry Potter books.
    
    source