Comment on Some interesting comments on the move

• logen@exploding-heads.com ⁨1⁩ ⁨year⁩ ago

  Like a nostr node, anyone can set one up and they can share information with each other.

  If you use Linux, you may notice that the keys are updated from time to time, that’s your system contacting keyservers to get a copy of the public keys to verify package integrety.

  But yea, they have a central authority, kinda, but really it’s just a place for people to store their public keys so people can use it to verify cryptographically signed content, or encrypt data meant only for the owner of the key pair that the public key is attached to.

  To me, it looks like nostr nodes do this, there’s just nothing implemented yet to recover a hijacked key. Tom (if anyone remembers him) could get a following of 10k people, happen to lose control of his private key, and then we are back to the same problem of a central authority banning someone… Possibly even worse because, well, identity theft without a way to proove it.

  At this point, at the very least, I’d like the owner of the private key (regular users) to be able to send a revocation certificate to a node which will flag this particular public key as compromised. Other nodes will see this and the flag will spread. Revocation certificats can only be made by someone with access to the private key. So we shouldn’t have any censorship issues here.

  tl;dr of everything I’m going on about here so far

  I’d like nostr to implement a way for users to print out revocation certs, just like how we can backup our private keys, so that users have the ability to report compromised accounts to the nodes.

  I’d also like there to be a system where we can recover from the above situation without having to start over and rebuild trust under a new identity. Such as having a backup key that can veryify a new key belongs to the person who’s claiming it.

  We already have a solution for all this, it’s just a mater of nostr nodes supporting it.

  source

  • masterofballs@exploding-heads.com ⁨1⁩ ⁨year⁩ ago

    Back up isn’t really a problem atleast. You can access everyone’s followers on nostr. Everything is public. Person to person messages are kept private with encryption. If you lose your PK though those all become public.

    source

    • logen@exploding-heads.com ⁨1⁩ ⁨year⁩ ago

      My problem lies with the identity theft and recovery.

      It’s the public followers I lose.

      If Masterofballs says, “Hey, I lost my old key, this is my new one, everyone follow me!” How do I know you are you? How do I know that the identy was even lost? How do I trust you are who you say you are? Especially if someone else has your old key and is impersonating you? Or, mehbe this new account is the impersonator.

      It’s a real problem for someone trying to maintain some sort of identity, which, to greater or lessor extents, we all are.

      If you just want to be anon, this system works well enough, but if you want to maintain your reputation… there are challanges we need to overcome.

      Or, since I really don’t know much about nostr, mehbe they are already working on this problem.

      Trustless systems need to be robust.

      source

      • masterofballs@exploding-heads.com ⁨1⁩ ⁨year⁩ ago

        I mean I know this isn’t a answer for everyone but I maintain like wolfballs.com . And I can post my information there. domain names are reasonably anonymous and so far has not been attacked by censorship. Other than that, keep your shit secure I guess. But yeah I can see the value in increasing that security.

        source

        • -> View More Comments