Comment on Why is it impossible to reverse-engineer closed source software?

• peopleproblems@lemmy.world ⁨5⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

  Instead of just getting the down votes, I’ll explain why that wouldnt work.

  1. The AI itself cannot decompile it without the same tools I would use. The AI would then end up with the same starting spot I have.
  2. Current LLMs do not know how to interpret code logic, and would likely make mistakes in Syscalls, register addresses, and instructions.
  3. Assembly languages themselves have nothing further than instruction sets. I’m sure there are ways to organize it in the super rare case of actually writing assembly, but not to the effect of object oriented or functional programming.

  Lastly, other comments have pointed out decompiled code is extremely expensive to analyze. The output from whatever we decompile would easily exceed the input limits for all existing LLMs.

  source

  • Naich@lemmings.world ⁨5⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

    Thanks. I was thinking that you could have an AI “looking over the shoulder” of a compiler, seeing what comes out for the code going in to it. Basically training it to spot sequences in compiled code in order to guess the instructions that compiled into that code.

    source