Comment on I don't think we should be rooting for the Bell Riots but the pin is funny
optissima@possumpat.io 5 months ago
Why not? The bell riots themselves was one of the steps to class consciousness, something we desperately need now. Yeah people were hurt, but how different is that than BLM and other rights protests being mass arrested or openly fired upon these days?
bigfoot@lemm.ee 5 months ago
That is a very machivellian attitude. I don’t believe that hurting people is justified, even if it were a shortcut to utopia, which it’s not.
BarrelAgedBoredom@lemm.ee 5 months ago
All of human political activity boils down to violence. If pacifism were a legitimate strategy then we wouldn’t be in our current situation.
bigfoot@lemm.ee 5 months ago
I didn’t say anything about pacifism, but I also disagree with your proposition equating violence and politics. Violence is a breakdown of politics. Politics, almost definitionally, is how a people settle disputes without violence.
BarrelAgedBoredom@lemm.ee 5 months ago
Pacifism is an ideology centered on political change through nonviolence. Maybe you didn’t explicitly say it, but you might as well have. Can you provide a source on violence being a result of political breakdown and not intrinsic to politics itself? How do current regimes uphold their power?
Politics is, more or less, how decisions are made in groups. Making a decision doesn’t preclude violence. Wars are political and their entire point is violence. Colonialism was foundational to the politics of the last 3+ centuries and it was incredibly violent. Besides vibes, what evidence do you have to support the claim that politics aren’t violent?
optissima@possumpat.io 5 months ago
I believe that people should defend their right to exist.
bigfoot@lemm.ee 5 months ago
I will engage with you in the context of your original proposition but I will not engage with Gish Galloping.
optissima@possumpat.io 5 months ago
It’s only Gish galloping if you edit your original message so they appear disconnected. You’d said all hurting was wrong, and my question was a direct followup to that.
Odinkirk@lemmygrad.ml 5 months ago
fern@lemmy.autism.place 5 months ago
OP looking like Image
aniki@lemm.ee 5 months ago
Chickenshit.