Comment

Comment on 'Alarming': 9-year-old girl attacked at school for 'not being Muslim' | WND | by Bob Unruh

Prove it, give me an example of what a “good” white supremacist is.

You still don’t get it, what would one good white supremists change? With one good white supremists would they become less of a threat? If a group has 10 murders in it does the group become less dangerous if the 11th is not a murderer?

Now you’re focusing on the semantics of an idiom which means “comparing that which cannot be practically compared” (source) rather than provide anything substantial that can lead me to agree with you. Congratulations, you failed at making your point again.

How about this. What makes the rarity of white supremists instances of violence incomparable to the rarity of Muslim instances of violence?

Because society is the example.

Here are a few specifics though, if you insist:

The British Royal Empire and impact on the slave trade

Slave migrations to the New World

Trail of tears

All rooted in white supremacy, all resulted in complete or partial genocides, all formed the basis of modern western society which still tends to treat people differently due to race/ethnicity.

You forgot that they all happened a long time ago. How does the trail of tears, slave trade, make white supremacy a danger today?

I want you to respond in kind with proof of your first comment that there is such a thing as a “good” white supremacist.

I’ve never made this claim, it’s a flat out falsehood on your part. I assume it’s because your whole argument hinges on this lie.

You haven’t backed up shit because you haven’t given an example of what a “good” white supremacist is.

I don’t have to, the rarity of bad people doing bad things in not affected by a good person being part of that group.

source

Sort:hotnew top

BobaFuttbucker@reddthat.com ⁨5⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
I can’t argue with someone who steps into a thread, tries to make a comparison, then refuses to provide a single example of why their comparison is right, then goes on to continually project that they’re the correct and rational one while it’s the other one that’s refusing to do those things.

I’m simply asking you to go first, since you’re the one that made the comparison. That’s all.

If you can’t do that then why are you even here if not to just project and troll?

source
- jimbolauski@lemm.ee ⁨5⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
  I can’t argue with someone who steps into a thread, tries to make a comparison, then refuses to provide a single example of why their comparison is right, then goes on to continually project that they’re the correct and rational one while it’s the other one that’s refusing to do those things.
  
  You are just stuck on a nonsense requirement that there by has to be a good white supremists but you can’t answer any of my questions as to why.
  
  I’m simply asking you to go first, since you’re the one that made the comparison. That’s all.
  
  I stated multiple times there doesn’t need to be a good white supremists provided rational for why, none of which you have tried to dispute
  
  f you can’t do that then why are you even here if not to just project and troll?
  
  If you are so eager to have a discussion then you would answer my questions or rebut my reasoning. Instead you keep repeating that there needs to be a good white supremists without providing reasoning.
  
  Here are some questions to ponder.
  
  what would one good white supremists change?
  
  With one good white supremists would they become less of a threat?
  
  If a group has 10 murders in it does the group become less dangerous if the 11th is not a murderer?
  
  What makes the rarity of white supremists instances of violence incomparable to the rarity of Muslim instances of violence?
  
  How does the trail of tears, slave trade, make white supremacy a danger today?
  
  source
  - BobaFuttbucker@reddthat.com ⁨5⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
    There you go projecting again.
    
    If you want the rest I’ll be happy to provide once you can give me an example of a “ good” white supremacist.
    
    source
    jimbolauski@lemm.ee ⁨5⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
    It’s obvious you can’t provide intelligent reasoning as to why I need to provide a good white supremists.
    
    source
    -> View More Comments