Comment

Comment on Doesn't the need for a permit fundamentally contradict the US's ideals of free speech?

Sensitivezombie@lemmy.zip ⁨7⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

The fact that the permit requires approval, whether it is always approved or not, it is still a permission to practice your free speech. Instead, it should be a notice by the people. This will allow the government to prepare for it. On the other hand, this notice should merely be a formality and not necessary.

In a real democracy, people should always have the right to practice their free speech that serves to protect the masses from exploitation or being oppressed. Furthermore, all public spaces are open to protest, whether they are in the middle of the street, in public squares, parks, inside and outside of government buildings, etc. The obstruction to traffic or anything else is merely a tool for the ruling class to act out violence against the peaceful protestors.

All universities, schools, and other places of knowledge whether public or private should be exempt from trespassing laws for the protestors.

People like to get technical about acting on your free speech versus right to free speech. This is a BS arguments that supports no one but the ruling classes.

In a real democracy, people have the power and government serves to obey the people, sadly, this is not the case in the US, and anyone that thinks otherwise are simply opportunist in the capitalist system or given in to the capitalist democracy propaganda.

source

Sort:hotnew top

morrowind@lemmy.ml ⁨7⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

All universities, schools, and other places of knowledge whether public or private should be exempt from trespassing laws for the protestors

Problem is, there’s a vocal minority convinced education is bad. Can you imagine the havoc if they could shut down any university without consequence?

source
- daltotron@lemmy.world ⁨7⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
  I mean maybe that would force the rest of us to actually take them as a serious threat instead of just letting them schedule big speeches on campuses that attract a bunch of out of town fans of theirs and financially organize.
  
  source
azulon@lemmy.world ⁨7⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
I don’t entirely agree: in a real democracy, government is an extension of people. They are hired brutes and managers that do the job that people tell them to do. So what if the majority of people collectively don’t want mass protests at the universities? Or that they want to be protected from masses of people randomly obstructing traffic?

Yes, it is possible for a government to use those restrictions as means of oppression: when people don’t even agree with those laws, but the government tries to shut the protesters down regardless. In such a case, a permit doesn’t even matter: just go out without a permit, because the government does not represent the people. If there were no permits, they would find some other loopholes to try and shut the protesters down: COVID restrictions, endangerment, (staged) complaints from neighbours, provocation etc. In Belarus, Russia, or Iran, they have millions of excuses ready to why all the protesters must go home or be arrested, the lack of permit isn’t even that common these days.

P.S. Also wanna point out: I’m not from the US.

source
- morrowind@lemmy.ml ⁨7⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
  What you’re describing sounds like a classic case of the tyranny of the majority
  
  source
  - azulon@lemmy.world ⁨7⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
    I don’t see it that way, but okay. And tyranny of majority could be interpreted twofold here: it’s probably a tyranny for the majority against protesters to tell them that they can’t protest at the university, but it’s also tyranny of majority for 10000 protesters to tell 1000 students of a university that they don’t care about their wish to study in peace? No?
    
    Surely if you live in Iran or something just as oppressive, protesting against the government is probably more important than studies and even in the eventual best interests of students. But at that point (as I mentioned), permits and restrictions are irrelevant: go protest without a permit regardless or whatever.
    
    source
    morrowind@lemmy.ml ⁨7⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
    Sure, though I’ve never heard of a protesters being the majority
    
    source