Comment

Comment on Chatbot letdown: Hype hits rocky reality

Ask it to search or list all of Bach’s children and you can see the wheels completely fall off. It was inventing people with actual fake birth and death dates and also gave me some of Handel’s children!

source

Sort:hotnew top

Creesch@beehaw.org ⁨7⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
What do you mean by “it”? The chatGPT interface? Could be, but then you are also missing the point I am making.

After all, chatGPT is just one of the possible implementations of LLMs and indeed not perfect in how they implemented some things. In fact,

What I am saying is that it is possible to implement search functionality around LLMs that is both capable and can be reviewed by a human user to make sure it is not fucking up.

Let me demonstrate. I am doing some steps that you would normally automate with conventional code:

I asked chatGPT

*“I want to provide a list of all the children bach had. What would be a suitable google query”

It then responded with.

“To compile a comprehensive list of Johann Sebastian Bach’s children, a suitable Google query would be: “List of Johann Sebastian Bach’s children names”. This query is specific enough to indicate that you’re looking for a detailed list, including the names of all the children, which should yield targeted results.”

The following step I did manually, but is something you would normally have automated. I put the suggested query in google, I quickly grabbed the first 5 links and then put the following in chatGPT.

The top 5 results in google are the pages I provided below. Browse to each page, and answer the query “List of Johann Sebastian Bach’s children names”. Just answer the query, but let me know if there is conflicting information on the page

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bach_family
www.classicfm.com/composers/bach/…/children/
bachonbach.com/…/faq-26-what-were-the-names-of-al…
www.spiritsound.com/music/bachchildren.html
www.grahamsmusic.net/…/bach-s-wives-and-children

It then proceeded to give me the following answer

Johann Sebastian Bach had 20 children in total. With his first wife, Maria Barbara Bach, he had seven children, four of whom survived into adulthood: Catharina Dorothea, Wilhelm Friedemann, Carl Philipp Emanuel, and Johann Gottfried Bernhard. With his second wife, Anna Magdalena Wilcke, he had 13 children, of whom six survived into adulthood: Gottfried Heinrich, Elisabeth Juliane Friederica, Johanna Carolina, Regina Susanna, Johann Christoph Friedrich, and Johann Christian

Going over the search results myself seems to confirm this list.

source