Comment on The brightest minds
5318008@lemmy.ml 1 day agoIt would be strange for **a person ** to say “we unpacked this topic” if you had formalized the topic, and I had not.
Do you agree?
Comment on The brightest minds
5318008@lemmy.ml 1 day agoIt would be strange for **a person ** to say “we unpacked this topic” if you had formalized the topic, and I had not.
Do you agree?
petrol_sniff_king@lemmy.blahaj.zone 1 day ago
But I’m not saying “we” have unpacked this. I agree, that would be strange.
5318008@lemmy.ml 1 day ago
Good, thank you. I’m A and you’re B. In this very typical usage, “We” equals “A and B”. As in, “We unpacked this” equals “A and B unpacked this”. You agree that this is the typical interpretation, here.
“A has not unpacked this” ⇒ “A has not unpacked this” or “B has not unpacked this” ⇔ not “A has unpacked this” or not “B has unpacked this” ⇔ not(“A has unpacked this” and “B has unpacked this”)(De Morgan) ⇔ not “A and B have unpacked this” ⇔ not “We have unpacked this” ⇔ “We have not unpacked this”
Then we conclude “A has not unpacked this” ⇒ “We have not unpacked this”, and so it is simply more specific. It is not possible for “We have not unpacked this” to be incorrect at the same time that “A has not unpacked this” is correct.
petrol_sniff_king@lemmy.blahaj.zone 1 day ago
I sincerely don’t understand what you’re doing here, man. I don’t mean the scary logical operators, I mean I don’t understand what it is you hope to win from this exercise.
The correction to “you” was me calling you slow. Uninformed, if I were being nicer. This… all of this is just more evidence of that point.
My job depends on me understanding them, actually.
5318008@lemmy.ml 1 day ago
What I’m pointing out is that it’s not a correction. I understand your motivation is to take cheap shots at insults. My motivation is to point out the logical errors you’re making so that you can put the rest of this conversation into context.
Don’t you think insulting my intelligence would be more effective if you didn’t make basic logic mistakes?
Yikes.