Comment on Anon makes a fatal error
Contramuffin@lemmy.world 17 hours agoI mean, realistically, the problem isn’t the money. The money is just a stepping stone to what the elites actually want, which is power. The power to do anything they want with no consequences and the power to control other’s lives. I doubt many of them even care about what happens to their money after they die. The damage is occurring during their life, not after. Castration solves nothing and is fundamentally unethical to boot
zarkanian@sh.itjust.works 11 hours ago
The problem is the money, because money = power. More money = more power. Sure, other things can give you power, too, but none of them are as reliable as money is.
Contramuffin@lemmy.world 11 hours ago
While true, I think your comment misses the point that I was making. What I am saying is that billionaires don’t want money for the love of the game or because they have things they want to buy. They want money for the power it brings. The elites would prefer to lose money if it means they get more relative power (ie everyone else loses even more money). Hence money is ultimately a stepping stone for their actual goal of power.
And the ultimate point is that this is a very fine distinction, because the logic behind the castration argument assumes that the observed societal consequences stem from continuous hoarding of money (ie, having money for money’s sake). It does cause issues for sure, just not the ones that we observe and care about.
Instead, if we acknowledge that what the elites want is actually power, then we know that castration will do nothing, since all the damage would have already happened by the time the elites die.
zarkanian@sh.itjust.works 11 hours ago
I think it’s funny that OP thinks that it would be easier to castrate billionaires than, y’know, tax them. I mean, if they actually did believe that and weren’t just trying to be an edgelord troll.
nullspace@lemmy.world 8 hours ago
Why not both?