But here’s the kicker, having the game being sold to you on a disk does absolulely nothing to prevent that. However, while we’re talking about how amazing disks are and how much we want our games to come on 20 bucks worth of additional plastic and how much we want to pay for readers to read said plastic, we’re not talking about how much it’s legal and normal for a publisher to require you to login in their system and periodically be connected to the internet so your game can exchange whatever the fuck info with their server, or else it can’t even run (legally). Because when you buy a disk, you own a piece of expensive plastic, and files on that disk belong to the publisher just as much as the files you download from a digital store.
Disks are dumb and it’s amazing that they’re gone, and we absolutely don’t need them to return. What we do need is the customer protection akin to stop killing games initiative, which will make digital purchase have the same legal protection as any other purchases.
Hell, if I was a conspiratorial sort, I would say the whole disk backlash started because sony wants to misdirect the public attention
Comment on GTA 6 players furious as physical copies reportedly arrive with missing or already-used codes
Hueristic_Autistic@lemmy.world 2 days agoThey just want to have the ability to rip it from your library. They just want you to never have access to the games that you purchased and will never call it renting because they want to keep customers.
We all know we’re renting by now.
Nalivai@lemmy.world 1 day ago
Hueristic_Autistic@lemmy.world 1 day ago
and files on that disk belong to the publisher just as much as the files you download from a digital store.
No shit but wight he disks you have indefinite access. They can’t wipe it from your system like cloud games.
Nalivai@lemmy.world 19 hours ago
No shit but with the disks you have indefinite access. They can’t wipe it from your system like cloud games.
Disks deteriorate with use, so it’s also quite finite of an access. And even though they can’t wipe the files themselves, they can make your game unplayable just as easily as they do with ones you download. Removing DRM is just as illegal as downloading and cracked version, so you’re not getting anything here. The world where you can just install a game from disk and just play it stopped existing long ago, and unless we do something with unregulated capitalism, will never return. And the problem here not the lack of piece of plastic in your possession.
Which leads us to the rest of your comment, which basically is a nostalgia for the times you were young. And as an old guy myself, I’m very sympathetic to your troubles. However, the return of The Disk will not help you get back to those times. You still will be a middle aged dude living isolated life in a crumbling civilization struggling to find meaning of that all.Hueristic_Autistic@lemmy.world 19 hours ago
There’s always a way with a physical copy. You can save you data externally not connect your console and then play the game. There’s ways to get there but I suppose the forcing of someone to log in the moment you turn on the console or else the console will not work, forcing people to use the internet and pay for a membership could kill that.
Either way, I guess I’m just an old fart that thinks that disks are cool and gives people a sense of they purchased something not just using a rental code and paying an upfront rental fee.
Yeah I know disks won’t get us back there, those days died out long ago.
ITGuyLevi@programming.dev 1 day ago
Well thankfully the supreme court already ruled that I can keep backups… Once I buy a game I like to think I can keep it, that’s why I’ve given up on consoles though, too many people want to control the thing I bought.