Comment on The brightest minds
HalfSalesman@lemmy.world 8 hours agoI take it you view anti-natalism as eco-fascism, even if it ideologically doesn’t even bring up environmental damage?
I agree that humans are part of nature, and that viewing humans as a plague on nature is dumb. I however do not see the positive of continuing our species, for the very individual’s within it. None of us consent to being born, and if only 1 in a million find their existence to be undesirable (and its a way way worse rate than that) then giving birth to a single person is rolling the dice on bringing about unjust suffering and is unethical.
But yeah, Human’s aren’t a plague.
YoSoySnekBoi@kbin.earth 6 hours ago
I don't view anti-natalism as inherently eco-fascist, no. I said what I did because the person I was responding to directly brought up environmental damage.
That said, I don't personally agree with anti-natalism as applied on any level larger than personal. There is no world in which a fetus of any species could ever consent to being born. Does that mean all life should cease to exist on principal?
I still believe that a person's reproductive choice should always be their own. If that leads to the extinction of our species, then at least it's what we collectively chose for ourselves. But I find it frankly insulting to women who want children to act like bringing them into the world is a morally unjust thing to do. In the same way, I view it insulting to women who wish to remain childless to act like not having children is morally unjust.
I truly feel there should be no moral imperative for anyone to have or not have children.
HalfSalesman@lemmy.world 6 hours ago
Yes.
Understandable from a women’s rights perspective, if you think that is what this is. However, my issue isn’t with whether specifically a woman chooses to have a child. Men can also want children and its also their choice as to whether they want to impregnate a woman. At least in so far that they do or do not engage in preventative methods with sexual activity.
I find both equally disagreeable, ethically.
Do you think having children is harmless?