We don’t have hard water, so I think you’re right. I wouldn’t save much time by having a dispenser versus a bar of soap.

I actually have a bar of soap right now, and I’m fairly happy with it, but I know my guests assume that it is less hygienic. It is important to note that I often use the dispenser for some reason instead of the bar of soap, even if I use the bar of soap fairly often.

Anyways I need an option that guests are comfortable with.

So its either having a dispenser, or a dispenser AND bar of soap. Currently we have both, but the dispenser is really small.