Comment on What is negative voltage?
TootSweet@lemmy.world 5 days ago
I’m not an expert, but I think I know what the deal is.
First off, the voltage of a single line has no meaning except relative to the voltage of another line. (Just like, say, “in motion” or “at rest” have no meaning except relative to a frame of reference. “At rest” relative to, say, the earth or the sun or the galactic center or car interior or whatever.) If you step on one rail of an electric rail line, nothing happens. You don’t even feel anything. If you step on the other, similarly nothing. If you bridge both, <southpark skier voice>you’re gonna have a bad time</southpark skier voice>.
“Ground” isn’t zero volts in any objective sense. And Vcc isn’t 5 volts (or 3.3 volts or whatever) in isolation.
And in fact, it’s only convention that ground is arbitrarily labeled “zero” and Vcc is 5 volts rather than Vcc being labeled zero and ground being labeled -5 volts. (Ok, it’s a little more than just convention. The latter would be awkward in practice. But it would be consistent, and you could do all your circuit design that way, just like if you labeled the white keys on a piano “Z”, “Y”, “X”… instead of “A”, “B”, “C”… You’d just have to think differently about it to make it work.)
So, I think what’s going on here, and we’ll pretend “Vcc” is 5 volts (relative to ground) just for the sake of this example, is that basically:
- The voltage differential between ground and Vcc is 5 volts.
- The voltage differential between Vee and ground (and the order in which I list “Vee” and “ground” here is important) is 5 volts. (If I listed “ground” and “Vee” the other way around, it’d be -5 volts.)
- The voltage differential between Vcc and Vee would be 10 volts.
So, for instance, if the device has some components that operate at 5 volts and some that operate on 10 volts (I dunno, let’s say the CPU requires 5 volts, but the… I dunno, optical drive motor?.. requires 10 volts), you can get 5 volts by using Vcc as my source and ground as my sink, and you could get 10 volts by using Vcc as my source and Vee as the sink.
That all make sense?
akunohana@piefed.blahaj.zone 5 days ago
That made perfect sense in the sense that I interpret it as yes, “negative voltage” - here - is a sort of figure of speech. We (or the article or the electrical engineering community or the universe) is not trying to say that there are negative voltages. The article is just illustrating the common voltage ranges for ICs.
Did I understand you right? 😅
cecilkorik@lemmy.ca 5 days ago
It is a figure of speech in the sense that voltages are almost always being discussed between two things, and the figure of speech part is that “ground” or “earth” is implied in most, but not all terrestrial cases. Especially in microchips, which like you said have very limited safe voltage ranges, it is very important to give them a stable and consistent reference to ground whenever possible to make sure static voltages don’t develop on the other side that can damage them internally.
Technically, if you’re referring to voltages on an absolute scale (not relative to each other) you’d typically be talking about “electron-volts” which is why powerful electro-magnetic radiation like x-rays, gamma rays, and other cosmic phenomenon are often measured in mega-electron-volts (MeV) for example. This is useful in physics, but just like we don’t use “absolute temperature” in day-to-day life, it is essentially meaningless to us standing down here on the crust of our pitiful little planet made mostly of molten rock covered in conductive water.
So in day-to-day life, we talk about voltages relative to the closest thing we have to a fixed reference point, and the “zero point” we rely on which is mostly a decent reference to the voltage of Earth’s own water table tends to be reasonably consistent and practical for our purposes. Static electricity is what happens when a particular object starts to lose its reference to ground, and large voltages (positive OR negative) can build up RELATIVE to ground, which then sparks when it finally equalizes back to our stable reference point. When large static charges build up in the atmosphere, they too eventually equalize with ground through lightning strikes. This is why “ground” is important to us. High voltages relative to ground can be very dangerous. Even small voltages relative to ground can be damaging to sensitive electronics. There is nothing special about “ground” voltage in particular, in fact it changes constantly with the weather, and solar output too! The important thing about it is that almost everything on this planet is connected to it, either through humidity, water, plants, the moistness of soil and even rock has enough conductivity to maintain a stable connection to Earth’s average voltage. And of course we’re going to use that as a reference and baseline because it’s super helpful for us. We don’t care how many electron-volts the Earth has. We just care that almost everything is connected to it in some meaningful way.
akunohana@piefed.blahaj.zone 5 days ago
Holy shit that escalated fast! In a fascinating way, that is! Thanks! So, truly, there is a measurable, absolutistic - albeit fluctuating - voltage (measured in electron volts) in the ground, but for our everyday appliances we rather measure voltage in the difference between the immediate source’s terminals, such as the two terminals of a battery, for instance?
cecilkorik@lemmy.ca 5 days ago
That’s my understanding, I think I’ve grasped at least the general gist of it, if not the specific nuances and details. Granted, I’m not a physicist or scientist of any sort. My dad was an electrician if that counts for anything, I dabble in electronics and I watch a stupid amount of Youtube, but those are pretty much my only qualifications, so feel free to consider this having a similar accuracy and truthiness level to that of generative AI, I won’t be offended.
TootSweet@lemmy.world 5 days ago
Well, to say “the voltage differential between A and B is positive” is saying exactly the same thing as saying “the voltage differential between B and A is negative”.
There is such a thing as voltage differential. And the voltage potential at one electrode can be higher than the other, or the voltage at one can be lower than the other. But given that “voltage” isn’t really a thing except in relation to something else, there’s kindof no such thing as “negative voltage” or “positive voltage”. Just voltage relative to some other electrode.
And if the voltage of one line is higher than the voltage of a reference (“ground”), then the voltage is said to be “positive”. If it’s lower, it’s said to be “negative”.
I don’t think “negative voltage” is any less a thing than “positive voltage”, really, but neither one is really a thing except in relation to a reference. Which is to say you can’t connect a single electrode to an instrument and measure the voltage of that single electrode. That would be meaningless to try. You can only measure the voltage of an electrode by connecting your instrument the electrode and a reference.
Hopefully that clears it up.
akunohana@piefed.blahaj.zone 5 days ago
This really helped visualize it! Thanks! 😊