Comment on Lemmy: fails the vibe check
balderdash9@lemmy.zip 10 months agoidk, maybe it’s the fact that the ones that do poorly/get downvoted are the ones I actually thought were funny. I sprinkle in reposts and those do really well. This is a trend that I’ve noticed since I’ve been on Lemmy. Guess I’m a bit raw about it.
whereBeWaldo@lemmy.dbzer0.com 10 months ago
Man I can really sympathize with you, It feels pretty bad to see your OC memes doing bad.
I checked the aforementioned 3 posts (I am talking about the “ass eating”, “crypto” and the “eye contact” meme just so that we are on the same page) and I often consider myself having opposed opinions than the general audience of those instances. I can see why people would downvote them since they are pretty much the opposite of the “popular belief” of the communities. But I have to say I wouldn’t upvote them either since they aren’t really that funny in my opinion (unrelated to any political opinions etc that I have).
The eye contact one is a really outdated format imo, the ones I find funny nowadays with this format usually have a very bizzare image that makes the meme funny by itself. People probably downvoted it because they found it misogynistic
The crypto one is basically just a rant so I really don’t think it has any comedic value tbh. This one probably got downvoted since it speaks positively of crypto.
The ass eating one was I believe the funniest one but I guess it just didn’t click with me. I don’t really have any mentions of race in memes but its probably the reason why it got downvoted. In my experience mentioning a (minority) race and not outright praising it usually causes people to downvote instantly.
Would I be able to make better memes with the same topics? Absolutely not. I just wanted to give my 2 cents about why the memes may not have done as well as you hoped.
balderdash9@lemmy.zip 10 months ago
This is really helpful feedback. Thanks for taking the time to write this out.