Abigail was my first, and unintentional romance. Actually all of them have been unintentional. But Abigail was my first, but I intentionally avoided giving her the bouquet. Thought 8 was shooting for Penny, ended up getting Leah first. But my third play through I (obliviously) went to the baseball game with Shane and got a hell of a surprise. I wasn’t angry or anything, just really unexpected. He got a bouquet but I felt weird about giving him the shell necklace. My only playthrough when I bought two bouquets.