Comment on Tumbler Ridge Shooter Created Mall Shooting Simulator in Roblox
tomenzgg@midwest.social 2 weeks agoMost people
An appeal to general consensus and definition by crowdsourcing is inherently anti-scientific.
kill a bunch of random people and then themselves for no good reason is mentally ill
I mean, clearly the scientist is who study these things didn’t draw that conclusion.
Being in a bad mental state is not, by any definition, an equivalent to being mentally ill. Mental illnesses are particular things, not a general blanket attribute for that person being “different from us” and non-standard.
And in this specific case, she was not a particularity stable individual.
Alright? I already said that some cases certainly involve mental illness. Your anecdotal pointing out won’t change the statistics and studies, though: those a minority if cases and generally incidental.
But you have demonstrated for all of us scapegoating in action: your entire comment disregards science and evidence-based assessment for an anecdotal definition based on a sense of normalcy that allows us to say, “Fundamentally, those people are just different from us. Normal people wouldn’t do that.”
It isn’t helpful, though.