SnotFlickerman@lemmy.blahaj.zone 14 hours ago
Was kind of excited to see something using the AT protocol other than Bluesky but then saw the big… “Login with Bluesky” and rolled my eyes so fucking hard while hitting the back button.
Until AT is truly decentralized I can’t justify joining up.
detectd@piefed.social 12 hours ago
Maybe they changed it because it says “Login with atproto” now
SnotFlickerman@lemmy.blahaj.zone 12 hours ago
You can use your own PDS, but to my understanding, you’re still using the Bluesky maintained PLC which manages the DID identifiers. That still makes it very much centralized and while you technically can self-host, it’s still somewhat tied to the BS company.
fwygon@beehaw.org 2 hours ago
Yeah this is problematic because once the PLC controlling entity decides they don’t like you or your PDS in general; they can simply cut your entire system off the federated structure.
Good for Deplatforming Nazis; but Bad for Freedom of Speech; if it’s used to deplatform more than any Nazi or Facist…
Then there’s the issues with having a For-Profit entity controlling the PLC. Bluesky is required by law to prioritize it’s profits and shareholders at least to some extent; if they ever become publicly traded. If they haven’t already.
I suspect we all will have to wait and see if this ever takes off in a direction we want it to. I don’t like how it looks already…as it makes control of your identity onerous and requires you to trust your PLC.
The PLC should be decentralized somehow. That might be something Bluesky has to kick off once they get the project off the ground and more users interested. We will see if they hold to their ideals; or if those ideals are misguided.