Comment

Thisshiws very well to what extent China is communist.

nationalizing industries: yes
making industries worker-controlled
private property partially abolished
workers’ rights even less supported than in USA
capitalist class being steadily empowered (they are getting increasingly rich and disconnected from the workers, even if their companies do have to follow the state lead than in more civilized countries)
wealth is being moved to the wealthy (albeit not nearly as fast as in USA)

Of course this only tells whether China is.following its own official ideology, not whether what someone else does fulfills that ideology or not.

source

Sort:hotnew top

Plurrbear@lemmy.world ⁨1⁩ ⁨day⁩ ago
But didn’t Trump want to privatize the postal service?

And didn’t Trump cut regulations for factories recently? This includes workers rights and safety. He bailed out Argentina and then China bought all their soy beans vs ours? How did that happen?

Cutting funding to rural farmers (USDA) and programs in the rural areas like food stamps, aid, etc.?

And the billionaires are ruling our country now as they do not pay nearly the same as taxes of an individual citizen, ie Amazon… etc. I feel like I am just a cog in a machine and have nothing to show for it due to rising costs on everything but wages.

As a child coming from communism, I know it’s not that bad as it was there and I believe or think the problem here is more about fascism but either way, I think I am just confused???

source
- PM_ME_VINTAGE_30S@lemmy.sdf.org ⁨1⁩ ⁨day⁩ ago
  
  As a child coming from communism, I know it’s not that bad as it was there and I believe or think the problem here is more about fascism but either way, I think I am just confused???
  
  Full disclosure #1: Lemmy has a lot of communists and anarchists. The Lemmy developers are communists and IMO it informs the design of the site. Lemmy.world has a liberal anti-communist bent IMO.
  
  Full disclosure #2: I am an anarcho-communist, i.e. a libertarian communist in the vein of Peter Kropotkin. Anarcho-communists and state communists have a glorious history of fighting like cats 😆.
  
  Full disclosure #3: I had a nice upbringing with a white family and I had lived in a rich American suburb for almost my whole life. Most people in my position are simply too comfortable to talk like I do.
  
  So here is what I actually want to talk about: it’s pretty bad here in America for most people! It’s worse than a third-world country in the rural deep South. Everywhere in the US, black and indigenous people are at best second-class citizens everywhere in the country, a system designed from the ground up to keep black people subservient and destroy indigenous people and uphold white supremacy. And Sinophobia has been a driving force in American politics since the 1800s. And we interned Japanese people during WWII, and even some Democrats use that historical comparison to justify what is happening to people detained by ICE. Healthcare is hard to get even for wealthy people. Mental healthcare is almost non-existent. Homelessness is answered by cops. School shootings are so routine that they rarely make national news anymore. Almost everyone is one big medical incident or one missed paycheck from homelessness. Our privacy has been gone for decades; we voluntarily carry mobile surveillance devices (cellphones) in our pockets. Workers have almost no rights. Dissent is only tolerated if it doesn’t threaten power, and while it’s worse under Trump, it was never really tolerated under any administration. The cops are tyrannical and completely unaccountable. We have the highest prison population per capita on the planet. We spend the most money by far on our military. Schools are physically crumbling and there is a teacher shortage because we don’t pay them enough. Infrastructure is crumbling and needs to be repaired, and even if we do repair it, it’s car-centric infrastructure so you basically have to have a car to survive in this country. Higher education is incredibly expensive but simultaneously expected even for entry level positions…which people aren’t even hiring for anymore, even in traditionally “safe” fields like engineering.
  
  I could go on and on and on. And everything above applies during and before the Trump administration, and it will almost certainly apply afterwards as well, because we don’t have an organized left and the Democrats are basically diet right-wingers who are literally paid not to rock the boat.
  
  Honestly: everything sucks here, we’ve been on the brink of a civil war for decades, and the only reason I haven’t left yet is because I don’t have the money to make the move. If I ever found the money to do so, I’d drop all my shit and be on a plane out of this shithole without even kissing my parents goodbye. I genuinely do not understand why people come here (although I welcome you nonetheless!) if you could go almost anywhere else.
  
  I’m not saying it’s not bad wherever you’re from. Just that it’s not good here and that you kinda need to expect that things are going to be trash in order to not get trampled.
  
  source
  - Plurrbear@lemmy.world ⁨1⁩ ⁨day⁩ ago
    Thank you so much for your comment! I appreciate and am understanding so much more unfortunately (because I am learning America sucks!! lol) and since we live here sadly they obviously want to keep us from moving away like we want for their benefit because with our the cogs there’s no “machine”, that’s what I am starting to understand.
    
    But honestly, your comments have opened my eyes and helped me so much with understanding the dynamics of what’s going on and such, so again thank you! 🙏🏼
    
    I honestly am feeling better about the comment from Trump but with my family background you can only expect fear, my Hong Kong family cannot even travel now because “their passports aren’t valid anymore” if they want to travel they have to get a mainland passport and all my family refuses. :/ I miss them…
    
    source