Traditionally, this rule applies to all Star Trek movies if you include Galaxy Quest (1999).

I eh

II Good

III ew

IV Fun

V WTF

VI Good again

Generations mid

First Contact Good

Insurrection no

Galaxy Quest very good

Nemesis odd

Star Trek (Kelvin) decent

Star Trek: Into darkness not a fan

Star Trek: Beyond fun popcorn

Section 31 just no