Thanks for answering :)
What aspects of advaita do you think lacks that Buddhism fills? What’s Kashmiri Shaivism? I know those two words but not that tradition.
Haha of course you’re Episcopalian. I was growing up. They’ve become quite open recently.
It’s a fun username :) especially for someone interested in various dharmas. Have you read into Jainism or Sikhism at all?
dharmacurious@slrpnk.net 3 days ago
Warning: religion, philosophy, nondualism and metaphysics are my trains. I wrote you a thesis before realizing what I had done. You’re not going to hurt my feelings if you don’t read the freaking book I just wrote. Lmao. Sowwy
I’m pretty new to TEC, to be honest. Grew up Baptist, but that wasn’t a good fit for various reasons, and sort of just did my own thing for a long time. Ended up finding the Episcopals when I decided I wanted to try going to church again. Helluva difference, being in a liturgical tradition, and I like it a lot.
Re: Buddhism V advaita:
So, it’s not so much about what one fills that the other lacks as it is about… Perspective? If multiple groups are all saying something similar, but with different focuses, intentions, inflections, verbage, et cetera, I think it’s interesting to examine both, find their commonalities and differences, and try to understand the underlying message. Buddhism speaks of emptiness, Advaita of illusion. While Buddhism tells us there is no self, advaita says there is no self except the self, the singular Brahman. I’ll be honest in that I am really new to Buddhism, and most of my advaita comes from Vivekananda and Ramakrishna and others labeled neoadvaita, but there is a lot of traditionalist thought and teaching in there, too. But I think, ultimately, they’re saying very similar, if not the same, things, and that by allowing yourself to float a bit between them you get to understand them a bit more. Kind of like how if you learn Italian and Spanish and Romanian you might have a much easier time understanding some old Latin texts.
Re: Kashmiri Shaivism:
If you’re at all interested in nondualism you’ve got to check out Kashmiri Shaivism! Very cool tradition. It’s a nondualism tradition, but with Shiva as the focus instead of Brahman. It’s independent of Advaita, and IIRC significantly older. Like, potentially Indus Valley civilization old. Prevedic old. Though, obvious any living tradition has changed in that amount of time. There are several really good YouTubers that do advaita info (and if you’re anywhere near NC then Swami Sarvapriyananda from the Vedanta Society of NYC is going to be in Raleigh in March, and I’m hopefully going to be there), but there’s less info on Kashmiri Shaivism. There’s the Kauai’s Hindu Monastery also called Himalayan Academy, but I don’t remember if they’re specifically Kashmiri or not, but I do think they’re ultimately nondualist, or qualified nondualists. I’ll look around and find some resources if you’re interested.
And yeah, Jainism is fascinating! Though so strict. I can’t imagine being brought up in that tradition. I have Catholic Guilt by association, and I’m not even Catholic. Lol. I can’t imagine what the idea of that strict an understanding of Karma would do to my psyche! Lmao
And I have actually just recently begun reading about Sikhism again! I love their ideas around universality of religions.
Are you at all familiar with Meister Eckhart? Turns out, there’s a Christian nondualist tradition!
Sufism is another really interesting entry point into Abrahamic nondualism, too. Though it’s a minority viewpoint even within Sufism, a minority trend in Islam, from what I understand. If you’re interested in that Tawhid is a good keyword for search and Let’s Talk Religion has an excellent video (or several) on Islamic nondualists and mysticism
I’m gonna stop writing there, because this is already a wall of text. Sorry!
ocean@lemmy.selfhostcat.com 3 days ago
I read your whole comment. I’m working on a PhD in religious studies so your in my field of interest ;) I will try to respond to you when I’m not on mobile
dharmacurious@slrpnk.net 3 days ago
That’s what I wanted to get my degree in, but for a couple of different reasons, I need to be able to go online, not in person, and couldn’t find a program at an online school that looked decent. Very willing to change schools for that if you know of anything! Religious studies is the dream.
ocean@lemmy.selfhostcat.com 2 days ago
What level are you referring to? Some in my PhD have been remote the whole time as the first two years were online then they just never came in person.